3 ms·
Good article! For those who haven't finished it, here's the bottom line: "ELLEN SCHRECKER, professor emerita of history, Yeshiva University: What Sokal was sho
by mcguire 10y ago
Good article! For those who haven't finished it, here's the bottom line:
"ELLEN SCHRECKER, professor emerita of history, Yeshiva University: What Sokal was showing was the downgrading of academic expertise. Historians go into the archives and we interview people and try to find out what happened from the evidence — rather than relying on secondhand information. Basically it’s a confrontation between a trained mind and a piece of evidence. This is what physicists do, this is what biologists do. This is what literary theorists do, too, but I think what happened to them is they ran out of new documents, and so they began to poach on the rest of us.
[...]
"What really bothered me was the inability of Alan Sokal and the other people who were responding to him to realize how this was playing out in the larger world. The hoax was very clever. But then he should have made the broader point about what’s really happening out there. I don’t think that things would have changed if he hadn’t written it, but he didn’t look around him and see that academic expertise was already under attack. Today is the culmination of 40 years of attacks on academic expertise. It’s fine if you want to make fun of deconstruction, but it’s not fine if you make fun of climate change.
"BÉRUBÉ: It’s widely accepted now that among the most controversial things you can do on a campus is deal with gender and sexuality, the Middle East, or climate change. I mean, they’re not exempt, the scientists. I didn’t think they would be, but it took some years for my argument to take hold. I said, the forces that are this anti-intellectual and this skeptical of what we do on campus, they’ll get wind of you soon enough.
"SOKAL: There is in American culture a persistent anti-intellectual current, which looks down on the pointy-headed professors and is happy to pick up on any excuse to have a laugh at them. That was the negative side.
"BÉRUBÉ: The echo chamber that publishes Sokal’s essay is so much less pernicious than the echo chamber that believes Hillary Clinton was running a child-sex ring out of a pizza parlor. Now we’re talking something well beyond epistemic closure and something much more like total batshit.
"SCHRECKER: What we’re reaping is an incredible moment of anti-intellectualism in American life, and it’s dangerous."
My take is that Sokal wanted to attack a specific, limited movement, although he didn't necessarily understand the nuances of who he was attacking. However, the result of his hoax was to give a freakin' big stick to them as want to attack those ivory tower eggheads with things like, "a majority of published research is wrong, and given that academics inhabit a very rarefied and solipsistic reality rather different from most of us".
- jccalhoun 10y agoMy perspective is biased since I am in the Humanities and I have seen people bring up the Sokal hoax many times. So, for me, the three most important quotes are: Social Text is not a refereed journal — if one of the founders was there and wanted it, it was probably going to go in.(...) The hoax gave people who had never read any postmodernist discourse, and didn’t have the slightest idea of what postmodernists like Derrida or Lyotard or Foucault and others were trying to do, an easy way to dismiss that project. All they thought they had to do was to invoke the Sokal hoax. That would be, in their mind, a totally sufficient put-down.(...) The hoax was not all particularly about science studies. It was about an academic culture. People in the humanities, especially people who were particularly ambitious, were aware that the fortunes of the sciences were rising in academia, and the fortunes of the humanities were declining. So to have a scientist sign on to poststructuralism was such a coup that they didn’t bother to read his article carefully.(...)
- Analemma_ 10y ago> However, the result of his hoax was to give a freakin' big stick to them as want to attack those ivory tower eggheads with things like, "a majority of published research is wrong, and given that academics inhabit a very rarefied and solipsistic reality rather different from most of us". This is just my own opinion, but I think you are 100% wrong here and the reality is precisely the opposite what you're claiming. The weapons used against science by the current anti-intellectual climate are the same ones created by the postmodernist/poststructuralist crowd that Sokal was trying to expose as frauds. His only crime was being too little too late. Even some figures in that sphere admit that things like the Strong programme laid the foundations for the current bad-faith attacks on science. Here's Bruno Latour: "[they] are using the very same argument of social construction to destroy hard-won evidence that could save our lives. Was I wrong to participate in the invention of this field known as science studies?" Claiming that Sokal was the problem, instead of the guy fighting the problem, is a pretty cruel twist on top of our current mess.