3 ms·
What happens to the woman on the picture displayed, though. If she survived, hopefully she deserves a share, too? Did she have to give consent to having her pic
by Tichy 17y ago
What happens to the woman on the picture displayed, though. If she survived, hopefully she deserves a share, too? Did she have to give consent to having her picture published?
- felixc 17y agoNo, because they are being used in a journalism context. A signed model release form would be necessary if you wanted to use the photo for, say, advertising. EDIT: That "no" refers to whether her signed consent is necessary, not to whether or not she deserves compensation. That is between the photographer, his conscience, and any damages he receives from this suit.
- jacquesm 17y agoGood point, I was wondering about that myself. Portrait rights? From: http://www.iusmentis.com/copyright/crashcourse/limitations/#portraitrights http://www.iusmentis.com/copyright/crashcourse/limitations/#... "Photographic works often are portraits of specific persons. They may, but need not necessarily be, commissioned by the portrayed persons. Many copyright laws contain provisions that require the author to get permission from the portrayed person when publishing the portrait. In case the portrait was not commissioned, e.g. a photo taken on the street, the portrayed person should demonstrate some likelihood of damage that can arise from the publication. A famous person could for instance argue that he normally charges for photos, and so the unauthorized portrait robs him of this income."
- cromulent 17y agoDepends on the local law, but in most places unless someone has a reasonable expectation of privacy then you can take their photo without permission. So, on the street, it's OK. In your living room, not OK. Getting pulled out of your collapsed living room - probably OK.
- jacquesm 17y agoThe photo the thread refers to is on the street.
- KirinDave 17y agoIn general, photojournalists don't need consent forms. In fact, in most places in the western world you don't need consent forms if the photos are taken in public, period. It gets a little trickier when it's a portrait or something. But if you go out on the sidewalk of a busy street where people have no expectation of privacy and start snapping photos, they really don't have any claim to the revenue from those photos.
- Tichy 17y agoI guess being half naked in the rubble of your house could be an interesting case then. Private or not?
- KirinDave 17y agoJournalism has different rules. But in general in the US the law deals with "Expectations of Privacy." If the party in the picture has a reasonable expectation of privacy then yes, consent would be required.
- acangiano 17y agoIn most countries you don't need a model release if they are going to be used for editorial purposes.