6 ms·
I feel that governments ought not have a right to my private financial information without a warrant. If they think I have committed a crime, they ought to be f
by briandear 10y ago
I feel that governments ought not have a right to my private financial information without a warrant. If they think I have committed a crime, they ought to be forced to prove such a crime. This is no different than every home having 24/7 interior surveillance with the hope that a crime could be discovered.
Governments, especially so-called "progressive" governments have the wrong belief that our money belongs to the government first and citizens are permitted to keep their 'share.' I know many people here think that a total loss of financial privacy is 'fair,' because of some sort of misguided class-warfare, however how would you feel if your entire computer and web history were transmitted to the government with the purpose of identifying crimes you might commit as opposed to being in response to a warrant that establishes probable cause that you actually committed a crime. Having money in an overseas account does not even come close to reaching a threshold of probable cause for tax evasion. However having overseas money (or in my case, a domestic French account,) doesn't mean you are a potential criminal any more than being black means you are a potential criminal. This is financial "stop and frisk."
In the US this loss of financial privacy and these 'disclosures' amount to a warrantless search. I welcome any counter argument.
Just to be clear, I'm not a 'fat cat' billionaire -- just an American living in France that has the 'privilege' of being taxed (heavily) by both the US and France. My French bank has to disclose information about my accounts to the US Treasury and I have to fill out an FBAR each year to 'prove' to the US that I am tax compliant, thanks to FATCA.
If it weren't for the obvious class warfare aspect, liberty minded progressives would be losing their minds over this violation of the fourth amendment. They'll howl over warrantless wire-taps but many remain silent with the financial equivalent of wire-taps.
I am not advocating tax evasion, nor do I support or defend those actually evading lawful taxation; I am opposed to a police state where everyone is a criminal until proven otherwise.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tomcam 10y agoEloquently put. I could not agree more. The US has a guilty-until-proven-innocent tax code and parallel court system run by the IRS whose Constitution-defying existence is baffling to me.
- bogomipz 10y agoCan you elaborate on how the IRS unconstitutional? Is it not covered by the 16th amendment to the constitution?
- esbranson 10y ago> parallel court system run by the IRS whose Constitution-defying existence > Can you elaborate on how the IRS unconstitutional? You have asked someone to elaborate on something they never said. Note you missed a key word, "court", criticisms of which are well documented.
- bogomipz 10y agoI see. It was not clear to me that the IRS court system rather than the IRS itself was being called unconstitutional in that sentence. Thanks.
- nrjdhsbsid 10y agoThe US govt doesn't take kindly to anyone hiding money to avoid taxes, whether that's setting up a chain of shell companies in the Caribbean or hiding money in the matress. I disagree with your premise only because any kind of financial secrecy leads to tax evasion, and taxes are how the government exists. It sucks making money over seas and that's because all the fat cats try to stuff their money over there. Nothing against you but a fair law treats everyone the same. Your argument rings of the "sovereign citizen" movement in the US which is basically a bunch of idiots that chant hail the USA while they simultaneously dodge the IRS.
- yardie 10y agoI disagree with you equivocating those that disagree with US finance laws to sovereign citizens. The fact is we are the only nation that have such far reaching laws that cross borders. It's completely ridiculous to think that what I earn and am taxed for in another country is also taxed in a country I don't physically have a presence.
- nrjdhsbsid 10y agoThe US government also historically goes to great lengths to protect its citizens abroad. For the most part, a US citizen sucked into a civil war or other terrible situation can show up at the embassy and everything will be okay. Might not be worth the amount of tax you pay but it's like expensive insurance in a way
- yardie 10y agoHistorically is correct. They would do that in the 60s, 70s, and early 80s. They don't do that anymore. When the civil war in Yemen turned really bad UK, French, and other western countries evacuated their citizens. The US sent a reminder that US citizens should leave. Outside of military the US does very little for its international citizens.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoAs far as I can tell, your argument seems equivalent to "private communication makes it easier for criminals to communicate, so let's make all communication non-private to make it easier to catch criminals". Yes, private banking makes it harder to catch tax evasion, and private communication makes it harder to catch criminals. Not impossible, just harder. Neither of those justifies removing that privacy.
- throwaway8918 10y agoU.S. bureaucratic lingo is hilarious (F[U]BAR, FATCA[T]). Follow the money: The civil "servants" and pension beneficiaries always profit most from such schemes. I'm not even sure that the progressives have much of a say here, though they're certainly useful idiots.
- tptacek 10y agoBe careful what you wish for. Enforceability is something that keeps our tax rates low relative to other countries (we have one of the lowest tax burdens among developed countries, not that you'd know it if you pay attention to our politics). If you want to see what happens when enforceability becomes uncertain, look at countries like Greece, which are the convergence point of the process that starts with the very wealthy being trivially able to escape taxation and proceeds, normalizing tax evasion by successively less wealthy cohorts of society, until virtually nobody pays their stated tax obligations, the government raises rates to make up for it, and the entire system becomes a joke.
- g81781w818 10y agoUh, what? Germany has a high enforceability and high tax rates. You can legally move to Monaco anyway if you're very rich...
- tptacek 10y agoGermany has in fact low tax compliance relative to Europe, and far lower than that of the US, which stands out among all OECD countries for compliance.
- praneshp 10y agoSource? (The other commenter is not going to earn a response from you, so I wanted to ask. I have a not-new account and my real name is attached to it).
- tptacek 10y agoI'm sure we can find a better cite than this, but for starters: http://reason.com/blog/2012/04/17/globally-speaking-american-taxpayers-are http://reason.com/blog/2012/04/17/globally-speaking-american... (It's easy to find cites for the claim that the US is abnormally tax-compliant, but not so easy to find tables like the one that article creates).
- halomru 10y agoI agree that disclosing all my bank transactions would be active surveillance and would violate privacy (even more so in countries like the US where cash is phasing out of use). But to my knowledge that's not what actually happens in western countries. Data reported to government agencies seems to always be limited to aggregates or data that acts like an aggregate (the amount of interest earned). I have a hard time seeing a privacy violation in that, since you provide a much more detailed version of that data to the government in your tax report. On top of that there's of course also the transactions that are reported to the government because they look like money laundering. That's more questionable, but I think it's still reasonable.
- return0 10y agoDont forget however that governments have legalized (with the justificiation to fight tax evasion) those illegally obtained CDs that make the rounds in europe. It could be any kind of information. http://www.dw.com/en/german-court-ruling-permits-use-of-stolen-tax-cds/a-6279679 http://www.dw.com/en/german-court-ruling-permits-use-of-stol...
- spoonie 10y agoAre you sure you're paying any tax money to the US? My understanding is that the US and France have a tax treaty, France's taxes are higher than in the US, and you are receiving tax credits for the income tax you're paying in France. You shouldn't have any obligations to the US unless you've got some income in the US while you live in France.
- pcl 10y agoI believe the OP was objecting to the notion that FACTA requires US citizens residing abroad to go to great lengths to document their foreign income, to prove that they aren't doing anything nefarious. Note that this is different than what US citizens residing in the states need to do, for a number of reasons, and is relatively new: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Compliance_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Complian...
- coredog64 10y agoThe IRS requires a number of conditions to be satisfied before they will allow you to file as an expat. It is also possible that someone can be paid in a fashion that doesn't incur additional local taxes but that the IRS sees as income. If you live somewhere that uses a VAT or import duties instead of an income tax, well, good luck getting a credit for that.
- return0 10y agoOur privacy is being violated by laws such as these, there no question about it. I wish there was a way to avoid this kind of information exposure, because i m afraid "accidental leaks" with unknown consequences will happen. These systems not only expose private information, they also duplicate it and many tax authorities don't exactly have strict security standards. IMHO it would be better if there was a system in place that allowed people to pay taxes in the country where their money resides and then pass the collected tax money to other countries anonymously.
- TheCondor 10y agoI agree with you in principle but there is kind of a logical problem as I see it. What does constitute probable cause for tax evasion? Should a tax man drive around with your recorded income and taxes and then make a values judgment based on you house, clothing and car? Being able to account for the contents of an account doesn't seem entirely unreasonable, I don't know what good alternatives are, just trust people to pay tax? I've been through tax examinations and it's not fun but what's a legitimate alternative?
- tn13 10y agoUS Tax policies are predatory and criminal in nature. The way IRS treats citizens goes well beyond libertarian meme of "Taxation is theft", it is more like "IRS is a mafia, more ruthless than ever". I guess at the heart of it there is "hunger of more of other people's money". The only way out I see is to put an actual constitutional upper limit on how much total money government can spend. Then the departments would be fighting among themselves possibly cannibalizing each other instead of our hard earned money.