2 ms·
There's already a health incentive to stay healthy, by definition. If people won't obey a health incentive, why will they obey a financial incentive? And there
by analog31 10y ago
There's already a health incentive to stay healthy, by definition. If people won't obey a health incentive, why will they obey a financial incentive?
And there's already a financial incentive as well: Discrimination provides a financial advantage to people who appear more healthy (younger, thinner, taller).
- nharada 10y agoStaying healthy is a really long term goal. You need to do it every day but there's no immediate penalty for not being healthy on a day to day basis. Penalizing someone financially is much more real and tangible than "that pizza you ate today is contributing very slightly to your degrading health"
- analog31 10y agoThat sounds plausible, but on the other hand, it also sounds plausible that the immediate discomfort of dieting for most people would outweigh the immediate financial incentive. An additional plausible explanation, that always has to be considered until it's eliminated, is that wellness reward programs don't work at all, but tap into the psychology of the HR managers who buy that kind of stuff. I was only thinking in terms of a simplistic "homo economicus" model, in which a worker acts rationally in their own best interest. If we abandon that model, I'm not sure we have a useful alternative.
- speeder 10y agoI disagree with OP point... but I also disagree with yours. For example, in the new year eve, my parents asked me my objective for 2017, I told them to become strong and healthy. Both of them were VERY skeptical, and thought it was absurd, specially because in their view, being strong and healthy won't make me pay my bills... And they are in a way, correct, to stay healthy you need resources and time, not always those are available, for example right now I am unemployed and have no contract, I have plenty of time, but no resources, and I am begging my parents to buy me some gymnastic rings I need for my exercises... but short term, I would be better if I stopped worrying for my health and went to get some short term job, even one blatantly unhealthy one (for example working with garbage). The thing is, I chased money (Because I was in debt) disregarding my health (out of necessity) from my 18 years until I was about 27 or 28... It is clear now the long term cost has been very, very high, my health is very damaged, yet if I had to go back, I don't think what I could have done differently, the path I took was the only path available to pay my debts, and in my country personal bankruptcy doesn't exist, not paying my debts wouldn't work.