5 ms·
> Those who don’t reach the targets in three categories have to pay an extra $1,000 a year toward their health insurance. It sounds a lot less sinister if you
by crazygringo 10y ago
> Those who don’t reach the targets in three categories have to pay an extra $1,000 a year toward their health insurance.
It sounds a lot less sinister if you rephrase it:
And those who reach targets in three categories get an extra $1,000 on their paycheck, that comes from the discount on their health insurance.
This kind of data should not be known/tracked by your employer ever, for reasons of privacy. That's totally different from your health plan knowing, however.
The deep question here, regarding all health insurance (including national schemes), is -- to what extent should you be expected to subsidize other people's intentionally unhealthy life choices? To what extent should people who make these unhealthy choices be forced to pay more for them? If I get diabetes because I drank 20 cokes a day...
But it gets even harder, because who defines healthy? The long-term effects of so many activities is so unclear, or under so much debate -- just like sugar, for example.
- bluedino 10y agoAs someone who works at a company that is removing all vending machines at the first week of the year, I agree. It's none of their damn business what people eat or drink and taking vending machines out just reduces employee morale.
- chrisseaton 10y ago> none of their damn business what people eat or drink Well if they're buying the food and drink and providing it to their employees then it's literally part of their business operations.
- gragas 10y agoIt's not their duty to regulate the private dietary choices of every individual.
- brianwawok 10y agoBut they aren't. They are giving a bonus to people that make good choices. Seems good to me. Disclaimer: makes good choices and am health nut.
- gns24 10y agoWhy do you think other people don't make the same good choices?
- brianwawok 10y agoI am at Walmart right now. I looked around. Other Americans do not make the same good choices I make.
- gns24 10y agoOkay, my question could be interpreted that way. My intended question was "Other Americans don't make the same good choices; why do you think that is?"
- tinbucket 10y agoI agree with that, but it's also not their duty to supply easy access to shitty unhealthy food either.
- chrisseaton 10y agoI don't think anyone in this thread argued that it was their duty to do anything. Everything we've talked about employers doing in this thread has been optional for the the employer. So you haven't said anything that anyone appears to disagree with. But I wouldn't say it was regulating. Can you see a difference between being allowed to eat and drink whatever you want, and requiring that your employer provide whatever you want to eat and drink? If your local shop doesn't happen to sell your favourite drink they aren't regulating you are they? That's just not what that word means.
- bluedino 10y agoThey are not buying food and drink - a third party installs vending machines on site and actually pays the business to do so.
- chrisseaton 10y agoI'm not sure that a minor business indirection like that really makes a material difference to what we're discussing. They're still providing a service to their employees as part of their business operations. People are talking about this like having cans of drinks is some kind of human right that they're entitled to. I'm arguing that it's a business decision and totally up to the employer. There aren't any laws, or I'm arguing any moral imperatives, that means they have to offer you any particular drinks.
- Asooka 10y agoI have a somewhat more practical objection - when you reduce their pay, how are these people supposed to get healthy again? Achieving healthy status seems more costly than maintaining it, but with this system, if you fall behind, your resources are further reduced on top of you being physically worse, making it even harder to get back to being healthy. It's like Mario Kart without blue shells.
- serb348 10y ago> It's like Mario Kart without blue shells. good analogy
- zepto 10y agoThis is how punishments work in general. They don't help people - they just weed people out.
- brianwawok 10y agoExcept it's not a cut for people who don't follow. It's a bonus for those that do. Anyone can get the bonus, just do the dance.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- izacus 10y agoHuh? Surely you understand that there's no difference between calling something a "cut" or a "bonus" when the result is the same?
- brianwawok 10y agoPerception my friend. Perception is everything. We give a tax cut to people with kids to encourage families in the US. How would people react if we changed it to a no-kid penalty paid by all people without children? Same thing right? But we would react very different to it.
- 10y ago
- gonzo41 10y agoIndividuals should pay for their own bad choices. Im in Aus and a pack of smokes last year (yesterday) cost $28. Today $35. thats for 25 cigarettes. Taxes work. In america it's a little more tricky, and nailing down the cause of long term conditions is also tricky. But if you're fat, smoke and don't do anything, and then you have a heart attack its kind of easy to link things together.
- jjoonathan 10y agoMy understanding was that obese people and smokers ultimately cost less to insure because they tended to die relatively quickly and with less prolonged fuss. Should individuals pay for their own good choices? http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/05/health/05iht-obese.1.9748884.html http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/05/health/05iht-obese.1.97488...
- gonzo41 10y agoInteresting read. I guess is a balance of extra productivity from not dying vs getting rid of some smoker :P
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoRetirees tend not to have much productivity whether they are dead or not.
- sten 10y agoRetired folk are (or can be) still an economic benefit as long as they live. Consider the trivial case of a grandparent watching children so the parents can have time to recover. But obesity and smoking do not kill people the day they leave work for the last time, it kills people in their 40s with years ahead of them to be productive.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- codedokode 10y ago> subsidize other people's intentionally unhealthy life choices Person's health depends not only on their choices. Some people are born more healthy and some are less. So does it mean that if somebody has errors in their DNA they should get less salary? It would be more fair just to make a tax for alcohol and cigarettes.
- gns24 10y agoSubsidising other people's unhealthy choices is clearly going to be a controversial topic, but I've come to the conclusion that the only sensible approach is to ignore the choices and threat the condition. Firstly, it's pretty hard to measure the choices people have made. Any attempt at measurement is going to add extra costs for little or no benefit. Secondly, we're judging people on things where we don't know the complete story. If a single parent is eating unhealthily and not exercising because they are short on both money and time, that's hardly something to make them pay for. If someone's been addicted to cigarettes for 20 years, they have probably tried and failed to give them up. To me treating wealthy people's skiing injuries should be at least as controversial as treating poor people's smoking-related problems. Personally I like to run to keep fit, but I view that as good fortune - I'm lucky that I'm healthy enough to run and that I enjoy it, and that I have time to do it. Finally if someone gets diabetes after drinking 20 cokes a day, they're definitely paying for that decision even without a financial penalty. In summary I guess that I feel that good health is a very fortunate thing to have, and I certainly don't feel entitled to extra cash for my good luck. The question here is as to whether this $1000 bonus/penalty changes behaviour or just rewards those who are naturally healthy/enjoy sport/like healthy food.
- glogla 10y agoI think lot of people see being overweight is a moral failure and want to punish people for it. That's all there is to it, no matter how cleverly worded it can be about "being healthy" and "subsidizing" and "choices".
- an_d_rew 10y agoSeconded! Being "healthy" is the realization of two interacting random processes: things that are in your control and things that are not. The tricky part is that the division between these categories is really fuzzy and markedly different for everyone. The link between cause and effect is also likely less simple than wellness models predict. Started running? You might feel good now but not realize that you're exacerbating the arthritis your genetics predisposes you to in 20 years. Stopped smoking? Awesome! But why did your employer put you in a state of constant chronic stress for 10 years resulting in elevated cortisol that resulted in a stroke? The path between cause and effect is very difficult if not practically impossible to trace out for populations. So although wellness programs are not as sinister as some believe, they definitely are not as nice or positive as they present themselves, either.
- sametmax 10y ago> It sounds a lot less sinister if you rephrase it A little voice inside me keeps repeating that it will not be like that in the long run. They will start saying it's a bonus, but years after years, it will transform into a malus in the calculations, like they always do. > But it gets even harder, because who defines healthy? +10. And the more you dig into health, the more you realize health professionals don't always have the best informations as you though they would. It's worth to take time to try many things on your own in parallel of traditional advices otherwise you can miss so many good practices, or engage in so bad ones.
- drewrv 10y agoDiabetes is punishment enough for your hypothetical gluttony. I see no reason to arrange society in a way to further punish sick people.