3 ms·
"It’s time the rest of the web ecosystem recognizes this and works to replace it with something open and distributed." Before Facebook there was FOAF, which wa
by Alex3917 17y ago
"It’s time the rest of the web ecosystem recognizes this and works to replace it with something open and distributed."
Before Facebook there was FOAF, which was exactly the same except for that it was open and distributed... And nobody used it. Being closed is the only thing that makes Facebook good.
- dasil003 17y agoYes, but what standards typically lack in innovation traction, they more than make up for in 800-pound-gorilla disruption.
- derefr 17y agoPresenting itself initially as Harvard's yearbook is what made it good, as it kickstarted its network effects (everyone feels sort of obligated to be "in the yearbook," because they want to imagine they will be reminisced about.) I've seen FOAF profiles, but I've never seen a FOAF network.
- Alex3917 17y ago"I've seen FOAF profiles, but I've never seen a FOAF network." Yeah, because no one is going to give 700 million dollars to a bunch of hippies to make some internet commune.
- mechanical_fish 17y agoI agree, but the point of being closed was the privacy. I have always believed that the secret to Facebook's success was the privacy. You were among your friends. Yeah, it wasn't private in the secure sense -- it wasn't secure enough to stop a determined stalker, let alone the FBI -- but it provided a social space that was different from just spewing stuff all over the open web. Now that they appear to have given up that angle and replaced it with an unpredictable tangle of spurious logic that, yes, spews stuff haphazardly all over the open web, why not just publish your updates in the open? What needs to happen now is that someone needs to go into Facebook's old business, the one they have apparently abandoned. Where is the closed service that makes a best-effort attempt to provide an invite-only social space for myself and my friends?
- alanh 17y agoFOAF is not a fair comparison. It meets only the "open and distributed" criterion. A Facebook replacement would, like the Wave protocol, allow users to chose a service as their delegate, and would not just be a way for nerds to mark up their meatspace and online-only friends.