3 ms·
"think the argument is fairly sound" No, it's a fallacy. There is an absolutely enormous number of possible humans that could exist, but don't. A presumably fi
by jerf 17y ago
"think the argument is fairly sound"
No, it's a fallacy. There is an absolutely enormous number of possible humans that could exist, but don't. A presumably finite, but enormous number. Neither of us believe they exist. I also don't believe in your existence (for the sake of argument), but you do. The difference is, you don't believe in 10^1000-1 humans, but I don't believe in 10^1000 humans.
No amount of stacking up non-existent things proves anything about any given thing, up to and including whether or not that thing exists.
Incidentally, this doesn't address any of your other arguments, which aren't really "in support of 'the (n-1) gods' argument" so much as their own independent, free-standing points. I just want to point out the (n-1) argument is a rhetorical device, not an actual argument of any merit. Perhaps "good rhetorical device" is all you meant by "sound", that would fit with the rest of your message, but I do prefer to reserve the word for its actual logical meaning; if we give that up we don't really have a replacement.