5 ms·
> I'm having serious Colin Powell UN flashbacks here: IC releases questionable data as justification for military policy decisions. Which military policy decis
by snowwrestler 10y ago
> I'm having serious Colin Powell UN flashbacks here: IC releases questionable data as justification for military policy decisions.
Which military policy decisions are those? What does expelling a few diplomats have to do with the military?
Nothing, of course.
I think this is an irresponsible comment. I think it's irresponsible to compare this to the run-up to the Iraq War when absolutely no one is talking about war. There is no ulterior motive or unfinished business between the Obama administration and Russia. As recently as 2012 Obama mocked Romney for calling Russia the U.S.'s biggest geopolitical foe. They're not, and Obama does not think that they are.
And I think it's irresponsible because you are relying on incomplete data (the DHS report) to attack a conclusion that rests on a much broader base than that data. And IMO, you're doing it knowingly, in an attempt to raise your professional profile and burnish your infosec credentials.
I have to say, though, linking to a Matt Taibi piece is not going to do that. He is an entertaining writer, but when it comes to cybersecurity, no one who knows what they are talking about thinks that he knows what he is talking about.
I use Wordfence and appreciate it. It's a good product. But I think you're on shaky ground here.
There's a saying that goes "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence." But the claim that Russia hacked the DNC is not extraordinary. The Russians hack, or try to hack, everyone in DC.
Within the last few years, they successfully hacked both State and White House unclassified systems. I don't recall everyone jumping onto the airwaves to dispute that assessment. Why? Because the govt did not issue any public data about it.
Now they have, in an attempt to help other institutions. Their thanks for improved transparency is a series of opportunistic misinterpretations, each of which hold up a limited report and declare it to be limited.
- Waterluvian 10y agoI think you're being myopic about the reference Mark is making. The way I read it, he's not suggesting there is a 1:1 relationship between the two, and therefore isn't trying to suggest the military has anything to do with diplomats. It's that the U.S. Government and alphabet soup organizations are providing scary but ultimately benign evidence in order to back policy decisions. We want into Iraq. How do we justify it? We want to keep Trump away from Putin, how do we justify it?
- snowwrestler 10y ago> It's that the U.S. Government and alphabet soup organizations are providing scary but ultimately benign evidence in order to back policy decisions. They are not! The DHS report is intended to provide govt information to private industry so that private industry can better defend itself. That's why it comes from the FBI and Department of Homeland Security, not the IC organizations who are actually tasked with attribution of foreign intelligence activities. In fact the Washington Post story, while overhyped in the headline, is an example of this in action--Burlington Electric applied signatures from the DHS report, and found a match. Yay. EDIT to add: No one wants to "keep Trump away from Putin," certainly not Obama. This is the president who said he wanted a reset with Russia--and by the way, was mocked by the GOP for saying that. What the outgoing administration--and career IC staff--want is for Trump to objectively interpret and apply the intelligence that is supplied to him. We don't have to think that Russia is our eternal foe, to acknowledge and react to a nasty thing that they did. Being our ally hasn't stopped Brazil from applying consequences to us for what Snowden revealed, for example.
- Waterluvian 10y agoI don't know enough about these topics to give you a worthy response, so I'm going to do some more research in the near future. Thank you for responding.
- mmaunder 10y ago> Which military policy decisions are those? What does expelling a few diplomats have to do with the military? Nothing, of course. "The Department of Homeland Security and the Federal Bureau of Investigation are releasing declassified technical information on Russian civilian and military intelligence service cyber activity, to help network defenders in the United States and abroad identify, detect, and disrupt Russia’s global campaign of malicious cyber activities." This suggests it is evidence of Russian activity. "These actions are not the sum total of our response to Russia’s aggressive activities. We will continue to take a variety of actions at a time and place of our choosing, some of which will not be publicized." This suggests we're going to be engaging in a classified cyber war with Russia. Source: https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2016/12/29/statement-president-actions-response-russian-malicious-cyber-activity https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2016/12/29/state... In the United States the only organization that can legally 'hack back' is the US military, according to the CFAA. So any cyber operation will be a military operation.
- snowwrestler 10y ago> This suggests it is evidence of Russian activity. The U.S. government is asserting it is Russian activity, and the information in the report is provided to help private organizations defend against it. The attribution rests in part on classified information and is not likely to ever be "good enough" for members of the public, even with the ODNI report due in a few weeks. And as I said below, I don't remember everyone jumping up to object when State and White House intrusions were attributed to Russia. Anyway, the fact that Russia is conducting a global campaign of malicious cyber activities is not news [1], and it's not fair to pretend that this DHS report is supposed to prove that on its own. > This suggests we're going to be engaging in a classified cyber war with Russia. War is a loaded term. Our war in Iraq killed many thousands of people and dropped an entire region into violent chaos. Is that what you think the U.S. government intends with the quote you mention? > In the United States the only organization that can legally 'hack back' is the US military, according to the CFAA. So any cyber operation will be a military operation. The military is also the only organization that can take out the trash in the Pentagon. My point with this flippant remark is that military activities are not commensurate just because they're military. Comparing the policy discussions of today to the run-up to the Iraq War is not defensible IMO. [1] So are we, BTW. EDIT to add: If the U.S. government wanted war with Russia, it has already passed up 2 perfect opportunities: - Aid the Ukrainian government in opposing the Russian seizure of Crimea by sending air cover or troops. - Declare a no-fly zone in Syria and shoot down a Russian jet. These were both real shooting war situations where force could have been justified. To think that now, a cybersecurity response is going to be the excuse for a shooting war, does not make any sense to me. I don't think anyone wants a shooting war with Russia. That does not mean we should ignore a material shift in the balance of intelligence activities we do to one another.