3 ms·
To alleviate concerns associated with commercialization, compensation could be limited to fixed payments or to benefit packages that include insurance, tax dedu
by maxerickson 10y ago
To alleviate concerns associated with commercialization, compensation could be limited to fixed payments or to benefit packages that include insurance, tax deductions for travel, lodging and lost wages, or paid donor leave.
Is there a coherent argument for creating a "market" where sellers are banned from realizing the full market value of the thing they are selling? I guess people will say gouging, but that doesn't really work for an organ market (2 kidneys are actually better than 1, there's nothing short term or unusual about the shortage).
- woofyman 10y agoPersonally I wouldn't want to live in a society where poor people are exploited for their organs so wealthier people may live.
- maxerickson 10y agoThat's what they are proposing. They want to limit the prices paid for organs to avoid people feeling squeamish. Case A: Organs can be sold for $10,000 only. Lots of people do it. Case B: Organs can be sold for whatever. Lots of people do it for more than $10,000. I find Case B far less exploitative.
- tomjen3 10y agoSo you would rather limit the oppertunities of the poor, rather than allowing them to make a choice about their own bodies that you personally disagree with?
- woofyman 10y agoYes...it's exploitation. Should people be allowed to sell their heart or their eyes?
- tomjen3 10y agoHave you thought it through? People will sell organs if they think that is the best possible opportunity for them. You want to come in and deny them that resource, which means you want to force poor people to make a choice that they believe is worse of. Either you hate the poor and want them to be worse of (I don't believe this) or you think you know that persons situation better than they do. We tried a system of tell people what to buy and sell and what to make. It was called the Soviet Union and it was demonstrately worse.
- gozur88 10y ago>Is there a coherent argument for creating a "market" where sellers are banned from realizing the full market value of the thing they are selling? Nope. The ban on organ sales is killing thousands of people every year in the US alone.