4 ms·
This is just data that matches previously expressed intuition. There are literally millions of un- or under- funded ideas out there that want to be companies.
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
This is just data that matches previously expressed intuition. There are literally millions of un- or under- funded ideas out there that want to be companies.
When you realize how much money the various public lotteries bring in every day, you can see that any idea that can skim off a nominal amount of "disposable" income from people who wish they were rich is going to do just that.
This is why I have always been opposed to loosening up the regulations around crowd funding investment. At least with a gizmo you get a gizmo, but for 99.9% of the people who have crowd-funded companies (according to the article, 1 in 1000 have been sold) do not have any return at all.
The part that annoys me is that it creates what is essentially a legitimate place for con artists to practice their skills, and enrich themselves, with no recourse for the investors. And as a result any "good" that might have come from allowing deserving companies to get access to a new pool of capital, you end up with a few bad apples enriching themselves and soiling the waters for everyone.
- theWatcher37 10y agoCrowd funding makes sense however when there is large consumer demand for a product deemed impossible or otherwise not desirable by major established players. Star Citizen is a great example of this as major publishers had no desire for a truly PC-centric next-gen space sim with very large worlds (4+ billion KM per face) and nested physics grids. Sure the end product is behind schedule but people backed it to break new ground, and that's exactly what it's doing. Something like SC would never be made under traditional funding models
- tptacek 10y agoCrowdfunding for products makes a lot of sense. But this article is about equity crowdfunding, which is crowdfunding not for presales of a product, but for return on investment. That makes substantially less sense.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jjeaff 10y agoWell if you say so, it must be true.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoI think you should use an example that actually ended up becoming successful in the long term (which is pretty rare). My observation with ANY type of crowdfunding campaigns is: because the founders has invested much less (both financially, socially, emotionally, etc.) in their projects, they tend to: 1. give up easily; 2. make bad decisions because they don't have much to lose 3. The fundraising is not really thought out, which results in most of them running out of money quickly and not meeting the deadlines. Imagine you're starting a company and instead of crowdfunding you decided to self-fund it until you get to product market fit. You would be extremely careful in projecting runway, and you would have done much more research before even jumping into the project. That's not the case with crowdfunding campaigns. Most crowdfunding projects are people who just throw up a web landing page with a video, hoping that it will go viral. Most of them don't even have any intention of building the thing if it doesn't go viral. This is why most campaigns are not well thought out and never make deadlines and most of them end up mediocre products, or better yet, not even ship. I can understand why there used to be regulations around this. I doubt anyone involved in these projects start out thinking they're going to con people, they start out with good intention but they bring down everyone along with them. Also because they think it's not that much of a deal for each investor (I mean, they only lose like $100 each, so what?) they can give up easily. Compare this to giving up on a company where you raised millions of dollars from your family, friends and institutional investors. You actually have responsibility to make something happen since it's not a matter of $100 investment each.
- Moshe_Silnorin 10y agoPeople have the right to make poor investments.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoSo is the flip side true? Do I have the right to clean out your parents bank account and get them to get a second mortgage on their house and give it to me, and then tell them, "Oh wait, it wasn't free energy after all, it was something else. Well, fail fast that's my motto. See ya!"
- Moshe_Silnorin 10y agoThat's fraud not crowdfunding. If it's a sincere attempt to start a business, crowdfunding seems like a fine idea. Though I agree, it is a lemon market and I wouldn't participate myself. Many people will lose money doing this, but the cost of freedom is some people will make poor investments.
- tptacek 10y agoIf it's practically impossible for the median consumer investor to tell the difference between a fraud and a legitimate crowdfunding opportunity, of what use is it for us to rhetorically isolate the frauds from our discussion?
- maverick_iceman 10y agoThe point is not whether the investor can tell the difference between fraud and poor investment. It is rather whether an actual fraud was committed as determined by a court of law. Investors should do their due diligence anyway.
- tptacek 10y agoBut that's not how publicly traded companies work. In practice, it's difficult to go public without substantial revenue, and your numbers have to be audited and disclosed through SEC-approved processes. Combined, these two factors have the effect of keeping most outright scams out of the major markets. Equity crowdfunding eliminates both of those guardrails. So it's reasonable to ask how effective they'll be (at generating returns for retail investors) given the obvious issue of fraud (and incompetence).
- aminok 10y agoAn economy is subject to evolutionary principles. A free market industry, like a hypothetical securities sector that doesn't have authoritarian prohibitions on free exchange, would evolve to become more effective at weeding out poor offerings. A subset of the population would still continue investing in bad ideas and losing money, but that is because they are gamblers, and if it weren't equities, it'd be something else they'd be friterring their money on. This evolutionary process was seen in cryptocurrency exchanges, which became less prone to involvency and hacks over time.
- rebuilder 10y agoYou could just as easily say the securities sector you describe would evolve more and more efficient scammers until investing became so obviously unattractive, the flow of money simply stops. Cue financial turmoil, riots, and perhaps the rise of regulation. Just saying something would happen doesn't make it so. Do you have examples of your scenario coming true?
- aminok 10y agoScammers are fighting a losing battle against the growth in public awareness. They can only capitalize on a state of ignorance. They cannot prevent people from adopting platforms and methodologies that have developed a reputation for good performance. I already gave you an example with the cryptocurrency exchange market. Other examples include people adopting Apple products as a result of it developing a reputation for quality, and platforms like eBay, Airbnb and Uber as a result of their rating system providing a reliable indicator of vendor trustworthiness.
- rebuilder 10y agoYour examples are companies that produce goods and services to consumers. We're discussing regulation of investing in such companies. Different cases. Setting that aside, I think it's far too early to say the crypto exchange market has improved. The exchanges remain pretty opaque still.
- zeroer 10y ago> a legitimate place for con artists As opposed to the lottery?