5 ms·
>We've grown accustomed to overporting our post-war suburban archetype of what a "middle class" family "deserves," i.e. lots of bedrooms, garages and lawn space
by closeparen 10y ago
>We've grown accustomed to overporting our post-war suburban archetype of what a "middle class" family "deserves," i.e. lots of bedrooms, garages and lawn space, while diminishing previously (and still!) common practices like having roommates when young, not owning a car, et cetera.
"People's lives are too good, we need to make them worse."
What's your angle? What do you gain from advocating against mobility and personal space? Are you upset because you didn't have these things, and don't want "undeserving" people to have them? Or do you just want us all to live in worse conditions for the fun of it? I genuinely can't understand what moves someone to push for "people should not have their own bedrooms or time-efficient commutes."
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> What do you gain from advocating against mobility and personal space? What works in the suburbs isn't sustainable in cities. Suburbia is built for personal spaces. It's terrible, however, at supporting the rich social fabrics densely-packed humans spontaneously weave. (There's also the problems of commute and it's environmental impact.) City-centre richness is a direct product of density. If everyone gets large, personal spaces you're back to suburbia and all its disadvantages. Living in a city means accepting less personal space in exchange for the benefits of density. The only alternative is to have fewer people with more personal space, which means rationing or auctioning off that limited housing as well as a less "city-like" urban core.
- closeparen 10y ago>If everyone gets large, personal spaces you're back to suburbia and all it's disadvantages. This is true on the x-y plane but not the z-axis. We can have substantially more sqft available per sqft desired in the same land footprint by building up, which is currently heavily regulated or outright illegal.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoI support more density, but the relationship between density and personal space isn't side-stepped by building up. You're just adding a vertical commute component. It's better than yards and boulevards, but a building of three-bedroom apartments to the edge of space will have a different human dynamic from one with mostly one-bedrooms.
- closeparen 10y agoWell first, a 1-bedroom is the most expensive way to live, at the rate we're going we'll have 3-bedroom apartments with 3 families per bedroom instead of 3 bedrooms per family :). Back to the Industrial Revolution tenements. You can get your human dynamic just fine on sidewalks, cafes, parks, etc. It doesn't need to be in-building. And even ~70 stories by elevator is still only a few minutes, nothing like the hour-plus train rides middle-class people in cities currently need to endure.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> You can get your human dynamic just fine on sidewalks, cafes, parks, etc. More density means fewer [EDIT: more] people within walking distance of each café, park and restaurant. That, in turn, affects how many of them there are and how eclectic they can be. Density is people over space. If you give each person more space, you reduce density. This can't be avoided. > nothing like the hour-plus train rides middle-class people in cities currently need to endure They don't need to endure it. Stamford, CT and Rochester or Port Jefferson, NY are nice cities with middling densities. But many people don't want that. They want restaurants and nightclubs and parks with rotating art installations that only emerge and make sense when you pack people together. Sure, you can put one or two large units in the mix without screwing things up. But not a lot, not for everyone. Else you end up with urban deserts.
- ghaff 10y agoI think you meant more people within walking distance.
- 10y ago
- wcummings 10y agoNot worse, just different. Times change. Maybe the lifestyle people expect and idralize isn't sustainable.
- closeparen 10y agoBeing unable to afford a room to yourself isn't "just different." The ability to be alone when needed is huge.