3 ms·
It's not entirely inconceivable that the middle class is 6% of the population, or less. Perhaps another way of thinking about the situation, is not that the mi
by analog31 10y ago
It's not entirely inconceivable that the middle class is 6% of the population, or less.
Perhaps another way of thinking about the situation, is not that the middle class can't afford traditional middle class amenities, but that the proportion of people who can afford those amenities is shrinking.
- alistairSH 10y agoIt's not entirely inconceivable that the middle class is 6% of the population, or less. <pedant>That's not how this works. Middle-class, is by definition, somewhere in the middle of the household income range. Exact position is open to debate, but you can't just declare "only the top 6% are middle class!"</pedant>
- analog31 10y agoThat's perfectly fair, and I don't think it's pedandic at all. Maybe we just need to re-think the traditional notion of the US as a "middle class society," and what that means. It conjures up expectations in my mind (house, car, kids, etc.) that might not be realistic any more.
- alistairSH 10y agoAbsolutely true. But with other posts throwing out $200k as a normal middle-class income, we probably need to define what we're actually talking about. The income range, or the lifestyle expectations. The whole point of the article (and others like it) is that the two things are moving in opposite directions.
- analog31 10y agoThat's a nice succint way of putting it, better than anything I could express.
- ryanSrich 10y agoThis is entirely my point and it seems I've done a bad job at explaining it. If a house, car, kids, etc is middle class then you need the salary to match it. What people are calling a middle class lifestyle doesn't match up with their definition of middle class income.
- analog31 10y agoIt's definitely the right point to make. I didn't even know the number myself.