4 ms·
Our rent went up 7% this year in LA, but our income didn't. The writing is on the wall I think.
by mixmastamyk 10y ago
Our rent went up 7% this year in LA, but our income didn't. The writing is on the wall I think.
- tptacek 10y agoIn what part of LA? What part of LA would you move to if your rent/income became untenable?
- Gargoyle 10y agoMuch of the city of Los Angeles is rent-stabilized, meaning rent can only increase up to 3.5% a year as long as the tenant stays there. But when the move out, the rent can reset to market rates. I just moved out of a place in Studio City, paying $1200 for a small one-bedroom apartment. It's listed now for $1600, and I'd bet on it filling within 10 days. So that's a 1/3 increase in rent I was able to avoid by staying in one place for a long while, but if I'd been moving around it would have cost much more over the years. In the far (semi-rural) reaches of Sacramento now, and happier for it!
- tptacek 10y agoRight, I get that. But that's true of every real estate market. The problem in San Francisco is that middle class families are priced out of every neighborhood in the city; their only cost effective options might be in another city. Is that true of LA? It's only the case if there's no reasonable neighborhood within the boundaries of LA you could move to after an untenable rent increase in your current neighborhood. For instance: it's obviously not the case that middle class families are priced out of the Chicago market. Chicago is full of neighborhoods full of hours and townhomes and three-flats that span pretty much the whole price spectrum. On the other hand: some neighborhoods that were pretty reasonable 10 years ago (Roscoe Village, or Bucktown) are now so expensive that their demography is changing. That doesn't mean Chicago is pricing out middle class families; it means Bucktown is.
- Gargoyle 10y agoLA is a MUCH bigger city than San Francisco, especially in terms of geography. I'm not sure an meaningful comparison can be made as a result. There are certainly areas of LA at least as big as the total area of SF where middle class families can not afford to live. There are also areas at least as big as the total area of SF where lower-middle class families are the vast majority of residents. The cities are just too different to make a meaningful comparison in my opinion.
- tptacek 10y agoRight, I get that too. But then: is the article correct? Are middle class families being priced out of LA?
- colordrops 10y agoI live in L.A. and as far as I'm concerned, yes they (we) are being priced out. You can live an hour away from your job or in a dangerous neighborhood, but that doesn't really mean the city is affordable.
- Gargoyle 10y agoIt's just a pointless question to ask if middle class families can live in the city limits (an arbitrary border) in my opinion. The better question is do middle class families have to live as far away from their jobs in LA as they do in SF, and the answer to that question is increasingly "yes."
- mixmastamyk 10y agoNear Hollywood. Have no idea where I'd move, we are already in the cheapest area I consider tolerable with a family.