3 ms·
I feel like one becomes a jacked dude with prison pecs by the experience of being in prison, and a Eucharistic minister by the experience of being somewhere rat
by geofft 10y ago
I feel like one becomes a jacked dude with prison pecs by the experience of being in prison, and a Eucharistic minister by the experience of being somewhere rather different from prison.
Which is to say, the crime-prone-ness of people currently under mass incarceration, were they to be mass decarcerated today, is probably not well correlated with their crime-prone-ness had they never been imprisoned in the first place. So if we want to model the effect of reducing mass incarceration, whether scientifically or by thought experiments with alb-vested street gangs, we should not model the effect of unlocking the prison gates and assume that this is an equivalent scenario.
(We can even talk about how life would have been for these people if they had been working in industries that weren't classified as illegal. For instance, if you wanted to be a major marijuana trafficker several years ago, there'd be a certain inherent underworld element to your life even if you never got caught, and the externalities of you living that life were probably bad for society. But if you want to do it today, YC or someone will fund you and the externalities of your life will probably be good for society. But that conversation might be too nuanced or too awkward to have in a reasonable fashion.)
- kapitza 10y agoAbstractly, this is a good thought. It would probably gain some nuance, however, by watching an hour or so of WSHH, 30 Sec Fights, even the First 48 or Bait Car: http://www.worldstarhiphop.com/videos/ http://www.worldstarhiphop.com/videos/ https://twitter.com/thirtysecfights https://twitter.com/thirtysecfights Or you could read anything by anyone who's had to teach in an inner-city high school. For instance: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/28/nyregion/new-york-teacher-gets-wise-at-a-hard-knocks-school.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/28/nyregion/new-york-teacher-... These are basically the types of people who are involved with America's criminal-justice system. There are certainly a few hard-working Mendocino pot farmers whose luck ran out, but the exception is not the rule. Albs or no albs, there may well be a way to turn these people into good traditional Catholics. I actually believe there is. But it's definitely not consistent with our modern vision of civil liberties. Our society has made a lot of efforts to help them let their inner human goodness shine forth spontaneously, perhaps more in the Quaker style than the Catholic. It doesn't strike me that these efforts have been terribly successful. Yes, an American prison is barbarous and dehumanizing -- but it's far from the only barbarous and dehumanizing aspect of America.