3 ms·
> But Russia and China don't go around enforcing human rights and their morality on other countries Do you have more details on this? Georgia, Ukraine and Syri
by prostoalex 10y ago
> But Russia and China don't go around enforcing human rights and their morality on other countries
Do you have more details on this? Georgia, Ukraine and Syria would be very interested in learning about Russian passivity as far as enforcement of their world views.
- dmix 10y agoSo a portion of Ukraine and Syria? What inconsistent values are they forcing on other countries? Which they attack other countries for not doing, but actively fail to follow themselves? I've given examples, I'd like to hear yours... US actively pushes human rights agendas across China, all of South East asia, Balkans, Latin America, etc, every time they do trade or diplomatic deal. Russia doesn't do this stuff at all AFAIK. They just occasionally demand unquestionable political support in exchange for support or outright annexation. They don't package in morality and human rights like the state department and executive branch of the US does. Russia and China seem pretty consistent with their immorality. But diseases are just as dangerous when they lurk silently and when the host is in denial they exist internally. And you can't go around playing doctor when you don't follow you're own medical advice. It totally weakens the message. It's easy to dismiss, even if the message is good and moral, it's ineffective. How is it going to stop Russia from playing dirty in the dark while pretending they are upstanding citizens in light? You don't hire junkies to get junkies to quit drugs.
- prostoalex 10y ago> What inconsistent values are they forcing on other countries, which they attack other countries for not doing, but actively fail to follow themselves? The question is kinda convoluted and involves a triple negative, but I'll try - aren't things such as "peace", "protecting human rights", "independent judicial system" and "equality of all people before law and court" some of the values declared by Russia? > Russia doesn't do this stuff at all AFAIK. Well, invasion of Crimea was later re-justified as an attempt to protect the rights of the Russian-speaking population (which quickly erased and replaced the previous message of "there were no Russian troops in Crimea"). Any conversations with Baltic countries involve protection of rights of Russian-speaking population within Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. Russian military bases in Moldova exist to protect the rights of the Russian-speaking population, and 2008 Georgia invasion was justified by human rights agenda as well. Military operation in eastern Ukraine was just a friendly and helpful gesture to help the [perceived] victims whose basic human rights were allegedly violated. And there's this http://www.rferl.org/a/russia-ethnic-russification-baltics-kazakhstan-soviet/25328281.html http://www.rferl.org/a/russia-ethnic-russification-baltics-k...
- dmix 10y agoI don't know, is Russia exporting peace and judicial equality in Crimea, Donetsk, or Syria? Was that a core requirement of their agenda when they intervened? I've never seen it being exported by them but I could be wrong. They seemed to be entirely motivated by preventing western power plays in their regions. I doubt they'd put serious pressure on the new Ukraine republics or Assad if they were acting authoritarian, suppressed political dissent, controlled the media, etc. Last time I checked that was happening in all of those places. Just as it is in Russia. But if they are doing that earnestly that would be similarily ineffective and damage their credibility. Worst of all you hand then excuse to ignore it, they can point out the hypocrisy and maintain their internal/external polticial support. That's the main point really. Consistency for consistencies sake it not the goal.