3 ms·
But Russia and China don't go around enforcing human rights and their morality on other countries. So it's not just superpowers playing their advantage. It's be
by dmix 10y ago
But Russia and China don't go around enforcing human rights and their morality on other countries. So it's not just superpowers playing their advantage. It's become a recent American diplomatic tradition to push hard on this stuff (externally) where it's convenient.
Not just the state department but Human Rights Watch and similar orgs often push an American agenda, where it often seems to be in coordination with the CIA.
Human rights include electoral freedom yes - but also freedom from unjustified violations of privacy by the state, free media, freedom of speech (silent all-seeing eyes chills people's speech via self-censorship).
That's why there is more of an irony or hypocrisy when America calls out a country like Russia which doesn't do this type of preaching. While simultaneously operating the largest and most effective sigint and hacking operation in the world, along with the rest of the five eyes. Their access goes far beyond what Russia or China could ever do thanks to all of the Internet backbone, mobile companies, and tech companies within their (and UK, Australia, etc) geographic range. Along with the five eyes having wayyy more money to spend on defence. While Russia's economy is the size of Spain.
So let be honest the only reason this charade works is because most people are oblivious to how this all works. It's just complicated "computer stuff". And those that do often rationalize it away as "everyone does it", regardless of unbridled scale - uncomparable in access to anything during the cold war - or the moral agenda being pushed by their countries.
Also the US seems much better at not getting caught (publically). When they do it's 3yr+ old malware, that their adversary was able to play catch up enough to catch, or no longer needed to hide the fact they had it. Old hacks are far less newsworthy and people move on.
The question is how long this one way street will be viable without blowback.
- WalterSear 10y ago> Not just the state department but Human Rights Watch and s similar orgs often push an American agenda where it often seems in coordination with the CIA. I would have disagreed with you until I watched the horror of Aleppo unfold quietly on the back pages for months, and then suddenly become breaking news the moment the 'wrong' side started winning.
- jamesgblaine 10y agoThis seems like a stretch as HRW has been one of the main organizations casting a light on CIA torture: https://www.hrw.org/news/2016/10/03/us-ex-detainees-describe-unreported-cia-torture https://www.hrw.org/news/2016/10/03/us-ex-detainees-describe...
- dmix 10y agoRed Cross exposed that not HRW. There was no way they could ignore that after it became public, everyone jumped on that. But without cherry picking the few times they did something, there are far far more times they didn't. Their politicized role in Syria is a great example. But there are plenty of other times they don't call out the CIA. One example: > HRW’s accommodation to U.S. policy has also extended to renditions—the illegal practice of kidnapping and transporting suspects around the planet to be interrogated and often tortured in allied countries. In early 2009, when it was reported that the newly elected Obama administration was leaving this program intact, HRW’s then Washington advocacy director Tom Malinowski argued that “under limited circumstances, there is a legitimate place” for renditions, and encouraged patience: “they want to design a system that doesn’t result in people being sent to foreign dungeons to be tortured,” he said, “but designing that system is going to take some time.” And their connections run deep: > The advisory committee for HRW’s Americas Division has even boasted the presence of a former Central Intelligence Agency official, Miguel Díaz. According to his State Department biography, Díaz served as a CIA analyst and also provided “oversight of U.S. intelligence activities in Latin America” for the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence.9 As of 2012, Díaz focused, as he once did for the CIA, on Central America for the State Department’s DRL—the same bureau now to be supervised by Malinowski. > One underlying factor for HRW’s general conformity with U.S. policy was clarified on July 8, 2013, when Roth took to Twitter to congratulate his colleague Malinowski on his nomination to be Assistant Secretary of State for Democracy, Human Rights and Labor (DRL). Malinowski was poised to further human rights as a senior-level foreign-policy official for an administration that convenes weekly “Terror Tuesday” meetings. In these meetings, Obama and his staffers deliberate the meting out of extrajudicial drone assassinations around the planet, reportedly working from a secret “kill list” that has included several U.S. citizens and a 17-year-old girl. > Her HRW biography, the vice chair of HRW’s board of directors, Susan Manilow, describes herself as “a longtime friend to Bill Clinton,” and helped manage his campaign finances. (HRW once signed a letter to Clinton advocating the prosecution of Yugoslav President Slobodan Milosevic for war crimes; HRW made no case for holding Clinton accountable for NATO’s civilian-killing bombings despite concluding that they constituted “violations of international humanitarian law.”). Etc, etc. http://nacla.org/news/2014/2/4/hypocrisy-human-rights-watch http://nacla.org/news/2014/2/4/hypocrisy-human-rights-watch Diplomacy is full of compromise and backroom dealing. I'm not naive about that. But it's hard to have an organization this big and influential without being itself compromised by agencies and agendas, without some real outward effort, transparency, and clear separation from the state - which I don't see here at all. Not to mention it having a natural slant from the various board members and financers who are all powerful Americans. But regardless you can't deny HRW is very slanted to US policy. It's impossible to follow geopolitics in the media without seeing their name constantly pop up in support of attacking Americas current adversaries of the day, in a very narrow way.
- electic 10y agoJust because China and Russia do not go around talking about human rights doesn't mean that they are not forcing other views on other countries. Russia is quite busy in eastern europe.
- mattnewton 10y agoI think that the reason they aren't seen enforcing views on human rights is many of their views aren't compatible with most American/European definitions of human rights.
- sremani 10y agoI am amazed how Europe and US refuse to engage with Saudi Arabia because of Gender apartheid. /s Not giving aid to Juntas that overthrow democratically elected governments like in Egypt. /s
- aioprisan 10y agoWe engage plenty, we sell them lots of guns, to the tune of $115B under Obama (http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-saudi-security-idUSKCN11D2JQ http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-saudi-security-idUSKCN...).
- smallnamespace 10y agoRussia wants a friendly buffer state. They couldn't care less the exact form of government in the Ukraine, as long as it's pro-Russia. Why? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enlargement_of_NATO#/media/File:NATO_affiliations_in_Europe.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enlargement_of_NATO#/media/Fil...
- ajross 10y ago> But Russia and China don't go around enforcing human rights and their morality on other countries. Russia literally invaded a neighbor two years ago...
- smallnamespace 10y agoThis might sound like sophistry, but invading a country is not the same thing as trying to export and enforce a country's own political ideals. If you just look at a map, NATO has been steadily pushing towards Russia ever since the USSR fell. They have legitimate security concerns and want to have a friendly government on their border, for the simple reason that Russia doesn't trust us. What they're not doing is dismantling the country and trying to rebuild it from scratch, like the US has been trying in Iraq.
- ajross 10y ago> This might sound like sophistry, but invading a country is not the same thing as trying to export and enforce a country's own political ideals. It's literally sophistry. Russia's "own political ideals" weren't merely exported to or enforced on Crimea. The region was annexed. It's now has precisely identical "political ideals", being, y'know, part of Russia. And the whole argument is sort of crazy-specific anyway, given the history of this region[1] has been one of a huge, Russian-led attempt to enforce a single political system on a giant collection of border states. [1] That, y'know, kind of led to that NATO expansion you're mentioning. Eastern Europe doesn't want to be dominated by the Russians again. Go figure.
- smallnamespace 10y agoCrimea really isn't a great example to hang your hat on, given that the population is majority Russian, was historically part of Russia before the creation of the Soviet Union (1783-1954), and by all accounts, the population wants to be part of Russia. Like, I'm all for the principle of no border changes through warfare, and we should object to the invasion on those grounds, but this is literally not an example of nation building, more like Putin wanting to take back historically Russian territory.
- prostoalex 10y ago> But Russia and China don't go around enforcing human rights and their morality on other countries Do you have more details on this? Georgia, Ukraine and Syria would be very interested in learning about Russian passivity as far as enforcement of their world views.
- dmix 10y agoSo a portion of Ukraine and Syria? What inconsistent values are they forcing on other countries? Which they attack other countries for not doing, but actively fail to follow themselves? I've given examples, I'd like to hear yours... US actively pushes human rights agendas across China, all of South East asia, Balkans, Latin America, etc, every time they do trade or diplomatic deal. Russia doesn't do this stuff at all AFAIK. They just occasionally demand unquestionable political support in exchange for support or outright annexation. They don't package in morality and human rights like the state department and executive branch of the US does. Russia and China seem pretty consistent with their immorality. But diseases are just as dangerous when they lurk silently and when the host is in denial they exist internally. And you can't go around playing doctor when you don't follow you're own medical advice. It totally weakens the message. It's easy to dismiss, even if the message is good and moral, it's ineffective. How is it going to stop Russia from playing dirty in the dark while pretending they are upstanding citizens in light? You don't hire junkies to get junkies to quit drugs.
- prostoalex 10y ago> What inconsistent values are they forcing on other countries, which they attack other countries for not doing, but actively fail to follow themselves? The question is kinda convoluted and involves a triple negative, but I'll try - aren't things such as "peace", "protecting human rights", "independent judicial system" and "equality of all people before law and court" some of the values declared by Russia? > Russia doesn't do this stuff at all AFAIK. Well, invasion of Crimea was later re-justified as an attempt to protect the rights of the Russian-speaking population (which quickly erased and replaced the previous message of "there were no Russian troops in Crimea"). Any conversations with Baltic countries involve protection of rights of Russian-speaking population within Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. Russian military bases in Moldova exist to protect the rights of the Russian-speaking population, and 2008 Georgia invasion was justified by human rights agenda as well. Military operation in eastern Ukraine was just a friendly and helpful gesture to help the [perceived] victims whose basic human rights were allegedly violated. And there's this http://www.rferl.org/a/russia-ethnic-russification-baltics-kazakhstan-soviet/25328281.html http://www.rferl.org/a/russia-ethnic-russification-baltics-k...