3 ms·
I found his old beef with his graduate advisor interesting. From wikipedia: "Zhang's Ph.D. work was on the Jacobian conjecture. After graduation, Zhang had a
by ithinkinstereo 10y ago
I found his old beef with his graduate advisor interesting.
From wikipedia:
"Zhang's Ph.D. work was on the Jacobian conjecture. After graduation, Zhang had a hard time finding an academic position. In a 2013 interview with Nautilus magazine, Zhang said he did not get a job after graduation. "During that period it was difficult to find a job in academics. That was a job market problem. Also, my advisor did not write me letters of recommendation." The reason behind this is that Zhang's research pointed out the mistakes made by his advisor Tzuong-Tsieng Moh's previous work. Moh was very unhappy with this and refused to write the job recommendation letter for Zhang. Zhang made this claim again in George Csicsery’s documentary film Counting From Infinity while discussing his difficulties at Purdue and in the years that followed. Tzuong-Tsieng Moh, his Ph.D. advisor at Purdue, said that Zhang never came back to him requesting recommendation letters.[8] In a detailed profile published in The New Yorker magazine in February 2015, Alec Wilkinson wrote Zhang "parted unhappily" with Moh, and that Zhang 'left Purdue without Moh’s support, and, having published no papers, was unable to find an academic job'"
His advisor wrote his own version of events here: https://www.math.purdue.edu/~ttm/ZhangYt.pdf https://www.math.purdue.edu/~ttm/ZhangYt.pdf
Crazy how this one guy derailed a genius like Zhang. Glad to see he found his way back, but sad that he had to endure almost a decade in the wilderness - at one point even homeless (living out of his car) - working minimum wage jobs just to get by.
- pmiller2 10y agoIt actually sounds like the "having published no papers" bit was the primary reason he wasn't able to get a job. Not having an advisor recommendation is not a good sign, but it's hard to argue with published work.
- ithinkinstereo 10y agoThat's a valid point. I know in Mathematics quality seems to trump quantity but having _no_ articles certainly didn't do him any favors. But the lack of LORs... that would be a scarlet letter, no? I've never heard of a PHD advisor doing that; seems quite intentional and not at all like the way he presents it in his little essay I linked in my last post.
- argonaut 10y agoTrue, but it's not unheard of for math PhD's to graduate with no refereed publications (certainly they'll have a thesis), so it really was the lack of his advisor's recommendation that killed his career.
- justicezyx 10y agoI don't think a PhD can get any interview for academic jobs at all without adviser's reference letter. It's worse than no publications.
- cma 10y agoIt is worth noting he already had a published paper before arriving in the US.
- mikebenfield 10y agoPublication rates in mathematics are much lower than in other fields, so the lack of publications isn't completely unusual. The lack of a letter from the advisor though would be seen as a major red flag.