4 ms·
> It's pretty obvious that cities and states should start eliminating pensions, but the beneficiaries of those same pensions are the people that need to do that
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
> It's pretty obvious that cities and states should start eliminating pensions, but the beneficiaries of those same pensions are the people that need to do that.
There's an easy way around that. "All existing pension-holders will continue receiving benefits as defined. All new public employees will receive investment-based retirement plans funded during their employment." Then existing pension-holders have no reason to vote against it. This also seems far more ethical, as it retains the guarantees given to existing recipients.
The company I worked for phased out its guaranteed-minimum-benefit retirement program, in favor of its standard investment-based retirement program, by doing exactly this: limiting eligibility based on initial hire date.
- w8rbt 10y agoI believe several states in the USA have taken this approach already. Some states made the switch soon after the 2008 real-estate crash and market meltdown. They have the old plans for older employees and new hybrid/stock market based defined-contribution plans for newer employees. Also, many state pensions aren't that great compared to California, etc. Employees only get 40 to 50 percent of their former salaries under a lot of pensions. I've never understood how California can do 80% pensions. The Federal pensions have some very high percentage too (not sure what it is).
- CountSessine 10y agoThe article says that El Monte did this - they abolished the supplemental top-up pension in 2008; but paying just those few who qualified for it from 2000-2008 is devastatingly expensive. I agree though - cancelling plum benefits while grandfathering existing recipients is the only politically tractable approach.
- candiodari 10y ago> I agree though - cancelling plum benefits while grandfathering existing recipients is the only politically tractable approach. How about the approach that was used in the 80s ? 20% year-on-year inflation for a while with the government lying about it saying it's 5% ? That "reduces" liabilities by 15% per year.
- CountSessine 10y agoAs an on-again-off-again libertarian, my preference would be for the government to do as little as absolutely possible so that we might never have to deal with public sector unions again. Then there are no incentives to lie.