3 ms·
> The reason we have these publications is that medicine is continually reevaluating its recommendations. The problem with nutrition is that for a very long pe
by pessimizer 10y ago
> The reason we have these publications is that medicine is continually reevaluating its recommendations.
The problem with nutrition is that for a very long period of time it wasn't, at all. It was citing ancient half-assed studies and anecdotes, never bothering to reassess or confirm them, and recommendations for low-salt and low-cholesterol are remnants of that time. I have no doubt that since a lot of that stuff has been called out, there will be money available for scientists to improve our understanding in the near future. My only irritation is that there are massive financial interests in maintaining the common wisdom, and that as a consequence, good findings will be ignored or suppressed.
As it is, the latest findings on salt and cholesterol are still not general knowledge, and the old common wisdom (as exemplified by popular science articles sparked by industry press releases, advice from primary care doctors) is nearly as dominant as it was before. A large part of that is that there's not been a lot of new advice to replace the old bad advice, leaving a hole, but the fact that statins and "diet" food are such a huge category creates a very dominant voice. That the loudest advocates for new findings come from faddish diets whose rationales reek of crank is also depressing.
> Finally, ask yourself: in the absence of evidence, is a diet that avoids fats/cholesterol (which, a priori, are associated with heart vessel disease[1]) such a silly idea?
We don't need science if we are just going to rely on easy, intuitive explanations of everything. Anybody can decide that eating fat makes you fat and fills your arteries with fat; you don't need any particular expertise for that.
- neutralid 10y ago> We don't need science if we are just going to rely on easy, intuitive explanations of everything. Anybody can decide that eating fat makes you fat and fills your arteries with fat; you don't need any particular expertise for that. Science comes in when you want to know how plaque consisting of macrophages containing fats/cholesterol on arterial walls are embedded, and how macrophage uptake of fats/cholesterol is increased/decreased. There's current work in trying to understand the role of TMAO (primarily from animal foods) in increasing macrophage uptake of fats/cholesterol: http://journals.lww.com/co-lipidology/Abstract/2016/04000/Trimethylamine_N_oxide___a_link_between_the_gut.8.aspx http://journals.lww.com/co-lipidology/Abstract/2016/04000/Tr... The research in this area is promising enough that insurance may derive TMAO-based measures of heart health: https://www.thepermanentejournal.org/files/Winter2015/ArteryDisease.pdf https://www.thepermanentejournal.org/files/Winter2015/Artery...