4 ms·
Left out of this equation is perhaps the most important number to buyers: price. All of these numbers show us how much more efficient it is to serve households
by rootusrootus 10y ago
Left out of this equation is perhaps the most important number to buyers: price. All of these numbers show us how much more efficient it is to serve households in urban environments, and how much more tax revenue it yields for governments -- but that is not passed along to buyers.
For example, the suburban house that I paid $350K for 15 miles away from downtown would cost a $1M if I wanted a similarly appointed condo in the city. And that excludes the additional taxes, building fees (which can be substantial), and parking costs.
- cma 10y agoHow so? Maybe other aspects of city properties are desirable and drive up the price, but the efficiency gains still apply and without them it would be even more expensive. Maybe you could get an even bigger house than your suburb one in a third world country for even cheaper.
- rootusrootus 10y agoA good friend of mine lives in a 1200sf condo in the city, and he pays almost $500/month in HOA fees. Isn't that a good proxy for efficiency? Unless the association is making a tidy profit. That's a bit more than my ongoing expected maintenance costs for this house are.
- someguydave 10y agoOften HOAs are nearly mandatory. Local governments love it when HOAs provide services (through extra fees) while the government also collects full taxes on the property.
- et1337 10y agoI think the idea is to get a smaller house in the city. I've been reading a blog called McMansion Hell lately (highly highly recommended), and it has a great article detailing some of the pitfalls of large, affordable suburban homes [1]. [1] http://www.mcmansionhell.com/post/150597521816/mcmansions-101-revisited-aesthetics-aside-why http://www.mcmansionhell.com/post/150597521816/mcmansions-10...
- emodendroket 10y agoLike a lot of this literature I think your blog entry is going to convince nobody but the converted. Especially the fatuous appeal to the fantastic construction of yesteryear. The crappy construction of yore is not still standing; that doesn't mean it never existed.
- thescriptkiddie 10y agoI think the article starts with the assumption that all other things are equal, ie comparing a $350K home in the city to a $350K home in the suburbs. Both homes will pay the same in property tax, but the home in the suburb requires vastly more infrastructure (roads, water, sewer, gas, electricity, telecommunications, etc) to support it for the simple reason that it suburbs are more spread out. Those costs are hidden from the homeowner, the city must absorb them. In the scenario where the home in the suburb is much less expensive than the one in the city, this problem is only exasperated because now the suburban house pays even less in property tax.
- rootusrootus 10y agoI guess I don't fully understand the problem here. Acknowledging that this likely varies by location; the 'city' I live in (Oregon City, OR) is a small town and completely tax-separate from the big city I work in (Portland). Not even in the same county. The folks in Portland aren't subsidizing my suburban lifestyle, and Oregon City is filled mostly with other homeowners just like me. So aren't we paying our own taxes towards our water, sewer, gas, electricity, and so on? My property taxes are lower than Portland at the same time that my infrastructure should cost more based on the analysis given in this article. But instead, I'd pay more in all regards to live downtown.
- hyperpape 10y agoIf you work there, then there's an infrastructure cost to your travel, office, etc. There are also some tax revenues when you do stuff in town. But you're by no means separate.
- matt4077 10y agoHigher density would mean the costs would come down. The $350k house doesn't cost that much because it's 15 miles from downtown, but because it's the 225,000th (made up number) closest house to downtown. Imagine you could miraculously cut 5 yards from the length of every city block. Your house would suddenly be a mile closer to downtown. But – assuming no reaction from the outside world – the competition for housing and the relative competitiveness of your house wouldn't change.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- scythe 10y agovan Mises wrote: "if a man has been run over by a car, it doesn't help to run it back over him in the opposite direction" Laws have supported the current norms in urban architecture for half a century. It is therefore the case that there are many more suburban homes and fewer city homes than the market would bear under a different regime. Changes to the regulatory situation would mean that a great deal of capital must be reallocated, and the costs will be absorbed by homeowners, i.e. innocent people. Urbanists must keep this in mind: what works in the long term will hurt in the transition.
- someguydave 10y agoThe price of all real estate is inflated because of government intervention in the mortgage & finance markets.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoor lack of intervention in the property markets? I don't know about the US but in the UK the only time we built enough housing was when the government got involved after the second world war.
- someguydave 10y agoThat's because both governments heavily regulate land use. I.e. You only building housing on your land with government permission.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoI'm not sure, the UK has relaxed it's planning laws in recent years but house building seems tied to the general economic cycle and way below what we really need.
- someguydave 10y agoYes but because land is so dear it tends to be the case that only high-end homes get built - ie expensive and low density. The basic problem is that land & housing prices are too high relative to people's wages. I think the reason they are so high is because of government intervention in the finance & housing markets.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoWhereas I think it's because of lack of government intervention in the finance & housing markets.
- 10y ago