3 ms·
You're ignoring the political context in which it was released. 1. Released the same day as the announcement of formal Russian Sanctions 2. Released the same
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
You're ignoring the political context in which it was released.
1. Released the same day as the announcement of formal Russian Sanctions
2. Released the same day US made 35 "diplomats" (aka. known Human Intelligence Officers) Persona Non Grata. Which is a big deal.
This type of document is not intended to "make the case" because we don't do that.
Making a case for something by definition, would reveal sources and methods which we highly guard. It also opens the administration up for scrutiny because there are many pieces which cannot be revealed because of classification - so it's impossibly to fully "make a case."
This type of report does however hint suggestively and point in the direction of support. They just let you put the pieces together.
In fact they don't have to put anything out and most people wouldn't even know to ask (outside of possibly FOIA, which won't go far in these cases).
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persona_non_grata https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persona_non_grata
- supergeek133 10y agoExactly this. If it was just a recommendation notice, why release on same day. Plus the thing is titled: "Russian Malicious Cyber Activity"
- cookiecaper 10y agoIt appears to confirm what we knew: the DNC's failure to adhere to basic security protocols, which would be enforced in any corporation with more than a couple dozen employees (edit: or not, see eropple's comment below), allowed its systems to be compromised by script kiddies (for political reasons, the USG insists these script kiddies are sponsored by the Russian government, and insists we take them at their word). This document says the attack would've failed if the DNC had watched out for SQL injection and if DNC staffers had not fallen for a phishing scheme. We're supposed to believe only a nation-state could've conducted these attacks? This is "Baby's First Hack" level stuff. This only further proves the government's propaganda policy for dealing with prominent cybersecurity breaches: blame it all on a foreign boogieman, as they did in the case of the Sony leak, so that the public doesn't catch on to just how very vulnerable all their electronic data is to practically anyone with the inclination to attempt to steal it.
- eropple 10y ago> which would be enforced in any corporation with more than a couple dozen employees No they wouldn't, and you are one of the people here who I would say should very well know it. :p The DNC screwed up, but the overwhelming majority of everybody else screws up to this level or worse on the regular.
- cookiecaper 10y agoYeah, you are completely right, and I completely agree, as I imply later in the post. Such mistakes are extremely common across the spectrum, at companies large and small alike (remember when American Express accidentally exposed an internal debugging application? [0] :O). Cybersecurity is still very difficult for everyone, and I don't mean to imply any differently. My quip was meant to emphasize that the security breaches described are basic, and likely could've been blocked if the DNC had, at the time, been following good security practice. Many corporations withstand such attacks routinely (and as you note, many don't). The penetration of the DNC was not something that required professional-level skill, let alone the resources of a nation-state. [0] http://www.securityweek.com/amex-developers-leave-debug-tool-open-world-including-attackers http://www.securityweek.com/amex-developers-leave-debug-tool...
- nutate 10y agoWhat it really requires is the blind eye (or knowing nod) of a nation state, since with the level of unuttered evidence (and the private orgs named which no one seems to be mentioning here) the idea that "we won't prosecute you if you do this" is the nation-state sophistication here. In the US you'd normally face justice for this, regardless of the locale or the ease of the break-in.
- perseusprime11 10y agoAlso the report doesn't say anything about not having your password literally be password!
- codedokode 10y agoWhile the methods used were very simple, I have an opinion why this could be done for some government or political party. The emails and data from a political party are probably very boring stuff, so a typical hacker would not bother to spend a lot of time sending thousands of phishing emails to get access to them. And later he would have to read through them to find some facts the mass media would be interested in. Usually hackers hunt for things like credit card numbers or fame.
- dmix 10y agoThe Obama administration announced they will release evidence about the hack in "3 weeks". So they will be making the case. It will obviously just be redacted.