7 ms·
Folks, the point of this report is not to justify the punitive actions taken today. It is to provide information that companies can use to protect themselves ag
by snowwrestler 10y ago
Folks, the point of this report is not to justify the punitive actions taken today. It is to provide information that companies can use to protect themselves against similar attacks in the future.
So if you judge it by whether it "makes the case" against Russia, it will be lacking. We don't need 100 comments pointing that out.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sigmar 10y agoIt seems notable that many of these comments are jumping on this for not providing proof that it was Russia, when that was not the intention of the report. The first page states- >This JAR provides technical indicators related to many of these operations, recommended mitigations, suggested actions to take in response to the indicators provided, and information on how to report such incidents to the U.S. Government.
- supergeek133 10y agoThe funny part about all of this to me, is that if most companies with data to lose aren't already taking these recommendations.. then they've already been cracked. Most of this report is pretty simple social engineering tactics/table stakes.
- parktheredcar 10y agoThe bloomberg article I read (http://archive.is/j5wRd http://archive.is/j5wRd) presented it as evidence. Maybe other publications are doing the same. >As part of the administration’s response, the FBI and Homeland Security Department also released a report with technical evidence intended to prove Russia’s military and civilian intelligence services were behind the hacking and to expose some of their most sensitive hacking infrastructure.
- grandalf 10y ago> presented it as evidence Quite predictable, since they also considered the wild accusations of various politicians of a high level Russian conspiracy to be evidence.
- gipp 10y agoIf you rephrase your hysterical wording as "major bipartisan concern across every intelligence agency and nearly all ranking members of both houses of Congress, including the heads of both Intelligence Committees," then I'm not really sure what more evidence you or I could hope for from such an obviously sensitive, active topic for the time being.
- grandalf 10y agoBy mentioning that they are "ranking members" you make an argument from authority that is predicated on the legitimacy of the government alone, effectively saying "kneel and take whatever they say at face value". In my view, they are all self-serving career politicians and none have shown any particular reason they should be trusted or respected. They were the ones who urged the knee-jerk reaction in Iraq which has cost trillions of dollars and many lives, among many other bad decisions that they all agree on.
- gipp 10y agoFine. But (assuming you extend this attitude to "the mainstream media" as well) you've created for yourself an ontology of the world in which it is impossible to claim any knowledge of anything outside your direct field of view. I'm not really sure how you intend us to accomplish much of anything without _some_ ability to trust _someone_ else. And bipartisan agreement from bitter enemies who have little or nothing to gain personally from such statements is about the lowest bar of trust I can imagine.
- hueving 10y agoPoliticians stand to gain government expansion when they scare the population. So it's not nearly as low of a bar as you think. It's like you're claiming we must trust pharmaceutical representatives from competing companies when they both agree that we all need more pills.
- chvid 10y agoAgreed - this is meant to present the evidence or at least the public part of. If this is all there is; then the skepticism coming from the incoming administration is warranted.
- gipp 10y agoYou said "Agreed" then said the exact opposite of what the parent said.
- 1_2__3 10y agoNot only many of these comments, but a few commenters jumping on the thread within minutes trying to repeatedly question or throw shade on Russia's role in this.
- walshemj 10y agowell I suppose their phones will work really well from now on wink
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoYou're ignoring the political context in which it was released. 1. Released the same day as the announcement of formal Russian Sanctions 2. Released the same day US made 35 "diplomats" (aka. known Human Intelligence Officers) Persona Non Grata. Which is a big deal. This type of document is not intended to "make the case" because we don't do that. Making a case for something by definition, would reveal sources and methods which we highly guard. It also opens the administration up for scrutiny because there are many pieces which cannot be revealed because of classification - so it's impossibly to fully "make a case." This type of report does however hint suggestively and point in the direction of support. They just let you put the pieces together. In fact they don't have to put anything out and most people wouldn't even know to ask (outside of possibly FOIA, which won't go far in these cases). [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persona_non_grata https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persona_non_grata
- supergeek133 10y agoExactly this. If it was just a recommendation notice, why release on same day. Plus the thing is titled: "Russian Malicious Cyber Activity"
- cookiecaper 10y agoIt appears to confirm what we knew: the DNC's failure to adhere to basic security protocols, which would be enforced in any corporation with more than a couple dozen employees (edit: or not, see eropple's comment below), allowed its systems to be compromised by script kiddies (for political reasons, the USG insists these script kiddies are sponsored by the Russian government, and insists we take them at their word). This document says the attack would've failed if the DNC had watched out for SQL injection and if DNC staffers had not fallen for a phishing scheme. We're supposed to believe only a nation-state could've conducted these attacks? This is "Baby's First Hack" level stuff. This only further proves the government's propaganda policy for dealing with prominent cybersecurity breaches: blame it all on a foreign boogieman, as they did in the case of the Sony leak, so that the public doesn't catch on to just how very vulnerable all their electronic data is to practically anyone with the inclination to attempt to steal it.
- apeace 10y agoThe report itself seems to claim it provides attribution. Am I misunderstanding? > Previous JARs have not attributed malicious cyber activity to specific countries or threat actors. However, public attribution of these activities to RIS is supported by technical indicators from the U.S. Intelligence Community, DHS, FBI, the private sector, and other entities. This determination expands upon the Joint Statement released October 7, 2016, from the Department of Homeland Security and the Director of National Intelligence on Election Security.
- buffasden 10y agoThe report is literally titled: "GRIZZLY STEPPE – Russian Malicious Cyber Activity" Yet it doesn't actually make a case for Russian Malicious Cyber Activity. People are pointing out the obvious spin on this especially since it's extremely light on technical details or a reason to exist other than propaganda. Reasonable companies don't need to be taught about phishing attacks.
- fab13n 10y ago> the point of this report is not to justify the punitive actions taken today. You mean the point of the persons who wrote it? Probably not. But the intent of those who decided to release it today? It most likely was. If so many HN commenters--sophisticated computer users and people with cognitive abilities way above average--feel like it doesn't go without saying, how many CNN or Fox News will realise it doesn't make the case against Russian? They'll just remember that some documents were released by some US intel agencies, proving that the Russians did "it" (without even a clear idea of what "it" might be), while the US govt punished them. That's good enough for people who saw no problem with going to war against Iraq because of 9/11. What worries me is that all of this Russian hackers + Fake News agitprop is that it looks like a perfect prelude to justify Internet censorship in Western democracies. When Internet allowed Obama to "steal" the Democratic party from Clinton in 2008, it was OK: maybe a bit embarrassing, but his policies weren't really that different from hers. But in 2016, with Sanders almost stealing the party again, and Trump taking the GOP then the general election by storm, politicians and their sponsors realised they didn't effectively influence voters through mainstream media any more. They've finally realised how scared they should be of Internet, and they'll want to "civilise" it, i.e. make it as controllable as billionaire-owned TV channels and newspaper. I hope they'll fail, but some of them will try to.