3 ms·
If bread costs 100 dollars per loaf, would that fit the definition of a "bread shortage"? If 90% of the US population is unable to afford to buy food and is go
by stale2002 10y ago
If bread costs 100 dollars per loaf, would that fit the definition of a "bread shortage"?
If 90% of the US population is unable to afford to buy food and is going to starve soon, is there a food shortage?
I would think so.
The literal definition of a shortage is that price is too high.
Everything ALWAYS has a price.
- linkregister 10y agoIn the bread scenario, the high price was driven by the shortage. That is, there isn't enough wheat physically available to fulfill the demand. Typical wheat production ends up with a surplus, which is stored, destroyed, or sold to lower-tier markets at a large discount. I see the point you're trying to make. But the point remains that the high price of a commodity is a reflection of scarcity, not the other way around. I didn't downvote you, but I'm assuming most commenters on HN don't want to be compared to bread or other commodities.
- RealityVoid 10y agoI don't see where you disagree with the OP. You say the same thing. > But the point remains that the high price of a commodity is a reflection of scarcity, not the other way around. I really fail to see the difference between OP and your point. Can you please elaborate?
- muninn_ 10y agoPeople aren't a commodity. Bread can't collectively bargain, improve it's own flavor to increase it's value, or start it's own granary. Comparing commodities to software engineers or what have you is be it's very nature an oversimplification and isn't very useful.
- RealityVoid 10y agoI agree with this point of view and it makes a lot of sense to me. If the price is high for something, that is indicative of a shortage. I fail to see how this can be in any ways controversial. On the other hand, I can't not notice that most readers on HN are very well paid SW engineers that profit from this shortage, quite handsomely sometimes. So it's understanding that posts like this will not be received on HN, it's the public's bias showing. On the other hand, I'm an Eastern European dev that is, while well paid for my location, still 1/5 as I would be in other locations so I'm incentivized to come and compete with other high paid professionals, so maybe this post is MY bias showing.
- user5994461 10y ago> On the other hand, I can't not notice that most readers on HN are very well paid SW engineers that profit from this shortage, quite handsomely sometimes. I wouldn't be so sure about that. It's the typical case of when you ask the guy next to you that does the same job and he's paid a lot less. Or when you ask you friend that are doctors/lawyers/finance guys and they all earned more than you. There is probably some folks on HN who's on the very top end [in their respective locations] but that's not representative of the usual dev.
- danjoc 10y ago> If bread costs 100 dollars per loaf, would that fit the definition of a "bread shortage"? Of course not. There can be plenty of bread, just a shortage of money. The government prints more money and then everyone can buy bread again. The literal definition of shortage is lack of the resource. Having US workers train their H1B replacements is not a shortage.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>The literal definition of a shortage is that price is too high. The question is too high for what? A bread price that is "too high" means people starve or struggle to feed themselves. When tech companies complain of tech salaries being "too high" they are simultaneously reaping massive profits, so they're not exactly struggling to survive.