11 ms·
The Asian American ‘advantage’ that is actually an illusion
- bluthru 10y ago>So while Asian American households seem richer on paper, many of them don’t really feel richer because they live in places where the rent is high and the groceries are more expensive. Ok, but other things like online purchases and college tuition aren't affected by cost of living. If you live in a high cost of living area sending a kid to an Ivy is relatively cheaper for you than someone in a lower cost of living area. Cost of living is high partially because there is higher demand for that place. Cincinnati isn't San Francisco.
- akhilcacharya 10y ago>If you live in a high cost of living area sending a kid to an Ivy is relatively cheaper for you than someone in a lower cost of living area. I don't disagree with your point but this is a very strange example. Most people don't send their kids to Ivies (most don't even think about applying), and even fewer pay full price.
- bluthru 10y agoMy general point is that college is a large cost that isn't affected by CoL. Same for vehicles.
- rwmj 10y agoI live near London so I'm a bit of an outlier, but housing is by far my largest expenditure, double that of food and approximately 7 times that of vehicles/transport. Also (AIUI) in the US most of the cost of education is in huge loans taken out by the child.
- bhc3 10y agoI guess it goes without saying that the headline is clickbait. The difference isn't "an illusion". Rather, the article describes an insightful way of looking at incomes based on cost-of-living for different geographies. The yawning difference between Asians and whites mostly disappears after accounting for geography. But it's still quite large versus other segments (blacks, hispanics). Based on the headline, I was expecting to see income convergence among the four groups. Not the case at all.
- tabeth 10y agoThis article sure is strange: >>The contrast between whites and Asians is particularly stark. Nearly 1 in 5 white Americans reside in rural counties, where a dollar goes a lot further. But 97 percent of Asian Americans live in or near a major city, where the cost of living is higher. By definition of living in a lower income area and subsequently making less money, you are unable to live in a nicer, high cost of living area. Personal preference aside, this means you're living in a more desirable area (for many, by definition) and these areas tend to have more job opportunities. >> Asian Americans, largely for historical reasons, cluster near expensive coastal cities. More than 25 percent of Asian Americans live in one of the four metro areas with the highest costs of living — Honolulu, San Jose, New York and San Francisco. Overall, about 73 percent live in metro areas with above-average costs, 24 percent live in metro areas with below-average costs, and 3 percent live in rural areas. This is basically irrelevant. One could also say, Black Americans, largely for historical reasons, cluster near more Southern large cities and towns (Dallas, Georgia, New Orleans, etc.) >> When we factor in these geographic patterns, the racial income gaps start to look a little different Yeah, Asian Americans still are making much more than Black and Hispanics. If this is supposed to negate the assertion many make that "For that reason, Asian Americans have often been invoked as a way to excuse the income gaps between whites and blacks or whites and Hispanics..." this isn't doing a great job. >> If you compare whites and Asian Americans with the same amount of schooling, Asian Americans actually make less money. They should also compare Asian Americans with Black and Hispanic Americans too, for good measure. --- This conclusion may be faulty, but I'm basically getting the following: for "elite Asians" (keep in mind, most Asians are not "elite"), they enjoy inklings of White privilege, if there's such a thing. However, they do not receive as much of said privilege as actual White people.
- BookmarkSaver 10y agoWhat he's trying to imply is that the place people live is affected by more than simple economics. There are differing historical and cultural reasons why blacks and Asians might live in different cities, regardless of their economic power. So controlling for their environment, Asians stand out less than they do just by looking at raw numbers. Compared to where they live, they stop outperforming whites, they just tend not to live in poor areas where whites also populate.
- tristanj 10y agoThis article has a glaring logic flaw. After COLA, Asians and Whites show roughly the same median household income. But among minorities, Asians still have higher median household incomes than their Black and Hispanic counterparts. The author barely makes an attempt explain why this is the case. Doesn't the data just reinforce the perception that Asians are the model minority? So what the article should have said, is after COLA, Asians still have an "advantage" over Blacks and Hispanics. But the illusion is that they don't do better than Whites, they perform the same. Which is not the illusion most people had in mind.
- Spooky23 10y agoThe problem is that those racial categories aren't very well aligned with anything. In 1816, this article would talk about how the Irish were a bunch of turds. If you look at "asians" you're looking at mostly confuscian based cultures and various Indian ethnicities, mostly admitted for residency for work purposes. "Hispanic" in particular is any of a dozen different distinct cultures. Statistically, hispanics are an overlay grafted on top of whatever other category you're bickered in -- sort of like how Jewish culture transcends nationality. A consultant from Spain and a mestizo immigrant from Guatemala picking tomatoes are the same, but have little to do with each other at all. I would assert that if you dig deeper into data you'd find that Asian ethnic groups are pulling ahead as a cohort in many ways in the same manner that the white ethnic societies did for white immigrant groups 100 years ago. The old boys club is shifting.
- mattnewton 10y agoThis, exactly this. "Asian american" immigrant family's disproportionately come here on work visas. This is a socioeconomic effect and afaik has very little to do with race.
- bluedino 10y agoPeople don't have negative stereotypes towards Asians like they do for blacks and hispanics. People assume they are intelligent. When an Asian man walks down the street, white peoples don't cross to the other side like when they encounter a black man. If you see an Asian in a BMW people assume they are a doctor or engineer, if you see a black person in a BMW, people assume they are a drug dealer, the car is stolen, or they play professional sports.
- simonsarris 10y agoJeff Guo at the Washington Post seems to be making some odd conclusions lately. For the study, Upward Mobility and Discrimination: The Case of Asian Americans, compare his reporting: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/11/29/the-real-reason-americans-stopped-spitting-on-asian-americans-and-started-praising-them/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/11/29/the-r... To Marginal Revolution's reporting: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/11/upward-mobility-discrimination-asians-african-americans.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/11/upw... It's like they read totally different papers. Or Guo is just gonna talk about whatever he wants to talk about regardless of what's on his desk, I guess. Which might be what's happening here. If you're really interested compare both of them to the study: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B8J_qdFYwNJ6TXdRVkM5S3lMNUU/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B8J_qdFYwNJ6TXdRVkM5S3lMNUU...
- gph 10y agoSounds like someone reads SSC :)
- themgt 10y agoThis is such incredibly poor agenda-driven "journalism", with cherry-picked data used to (poorly) attack a sort of straw man argument: Asian Americans seem to offer proof that minorities can prosper — and even leapfrog whites — if they work hard and jump through the right hoops. For that reason, Asian Americans have often been invoked as a way to excuse the income gaps between whites and blacks or whites and Hispanics. So even assuming the (unconvincing) argument that where asians live can account for the fact they are more successful than whites, how does their nonetheless COL-adjusted near parity (still ahead!) vs. whites undermine the idea that minorities can succeed in the USA? It's easy and cheap to virtue-signal your care for this difficult problem, but the elephants in the room here are IQ and culture, and mainstream liberalism is frankly bordering on fraudulence with its refusal to confront these topics. If you actually care about fixing the worsening income and wealth gap between races - and I would suggest everyone should, as it is clearly toxic to our social fabric - it's long past time to have honest conversations about all of the potential underlying causes and possible solutions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- BookmarkSaver 10y agoThere is also this, by the same author: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/11/19/the-real-secret-to-asian-american-success-was-not-education/?utm_term=.8858dbdb01b4 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/11/19/the-r... Basically, when you control for education level, Asians come out just behind whites while black and Hispanic minorities still get shafted. And that this didn't used to be the case, that Asians used to have a similar gap, which indicates that Americans have simply gotten less racist towards them. Presumably on such a large scale there shouldn't be a significant discrepancy of income for the same level of education.
- wutbrodo 10y ago> Basically, when you control for education level, Asians come out just behind whites while black and Hispanic minorities still get shafted. The Post conveniently leaves out important parts of the paper's findings because it contradicts the conclusion they wanted to draw: The process of institutional economic discrimination against Asians in America was equal to and in many cases stronger than that against black Americans. Hillger's paper argues that, once institutional discrimination was lifted, high-gradient societal discrimination was no match for market forces (suppressed wages for the same productivity from an Asian employee is an opportunity for easy arbitrage by a competent capitalist). These market forces did not have a similar convergence-to-white-income effect on the black labor pool, and Hillger's paper uses measures of productivity not dependent on education to at largely explain the variation. I'm of the opinion that statistical discrimination is pretty messed up too, so this doesn't mean everything is right with the world and no further problems with racism exist. I also get that many people think that statistical racial discrimination is warranted, which leads to the kind of mental backflips necessary to write an article like this. But that doesn't change the fact that pretending that productivity differences are irrelevant is simply bad reporting by the Post: At best, it's shockingly shoddy and at worst it's simply dishonest. Hillger's original paper: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B8J_qdFYwNJ6TXdRVkM5S3lMNUU/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B8J_qdFYwNJ6TXdRVkM5S3lMNUU... Some more concise analysis with excerpts from the paper: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/11/upward-mobility-discrimination-asians-african-americans.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/11/upw...
- scythe 10y agoIt has to be noted that Asian people still drastically out-earn black people and are roughly "equal" with white people by city. Really the data shows that discrimination is more anti-black than it is pro-white (I think it would be helpful if Hispanics could be stratified by generation). It's also revealing of the author's personal biases that he considers living in expensive coastal cities to be a disadvantage. In nearly every other context it's considered an advantage, despite the cost of living; imported goods and travel are cheaper, and infrastructure is nicer. The education system also tends to be better in rich cities, although it is worse in California due to Proposition 13. Having tenure in growing cities (and therefore owning property) is also a significant advantage in terms of wealth. Someone who bought a $200,000 house in Indianapolis in 1980 is doing a lot worse than someone who bought a $200,000 house in LA in 1980. Of course the really old money everywhere is dominated by white people, but most white people don't have access to that.
- RoboticFoot 10y ago> Really the data shows that discrimination is more anti-black than it is pro-white Or it shows that there is something about the statistically average black person that makes them less successful than the statistically average asian person. I don't claim to know what the difference is, but this is a fairly obvious inference to make. I'd actually say this is, a priori, a lot more likely than "everyone coincidentally discriminates against these particular racial groups but not any of these other ones". My suspicion (not based on any hard evidence) is that much of this difference is accounted for by the vast and obvious cultural differences between the average asian person in the US and the average black person in the US. Most Asian (South or East) immigrant cultures in the US aggressively push for educational and professional success. Black culture in the US doesn't.
- pessimizer 10y ago> I'd actually say this is, a priori, a lot more likely than "everyone coincidentally discriminates against these particular racial groups but not any of these other ones". How would you change that prior if you were informed one of those groups had been enslaved on the basis of race for a couple of centuries, ruthlessly oppressed for another century, then blamed for most of the problems in the country for the lion's share of the next one, becoming the primary subject of every leadership discussion? > Most Asian (South or East) immigrant cultures in the US aggressively push for educational and professional success. Black culture in the US doesn't. Educational attainment is more difficult to translate into professional success for blacks in the US; black college graduates have twice the unemployment rate as white college graduates[1]. With the rising costs of education and the yawning gap between white wealth and black wealth, the value proposition is only becoming worse. In my experience black people think that their best chance of success lies in sales and/or entrepreneurship. The only other choice is being the best of the best. [1] http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2014/05/when-a-degree-is-no-guarantee/371613/ http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2014/05/when-a-...
- paganel 10y ago> It's easy and cheap to virtue-signal your care for this difficult problem, but the elephants in the room here are IQ and culture I don't care about IQ, but supposedly you can't tell black people to just open a book (or two, or three) and to spend more time on studying because that's racist. It is their culture to sing and care only about Italian hyper-cars and jewels (we've come a long way since the days of Public Enemy) and that's about it. Doing anything else as a black person supposedly means that you're "acting white".
- politician 10y agoIt's unlikely that simply formatting your comment as "we can't say X about group Y because it's politically dangerous" is enough to prevent this comment from being flagged as intrinsically bigoted/racist, so you might want to self-moderate.
- paganel 10y agoI thought about that before pressing submit and then I remembered that my mother's skin is "brown", the same as my brother's (I was the "lucky" one between me and my brother who inherited the "white" skin from my dad), that they both (my mother and my brother) have been called "gipsies" because of that, and that I've been thinking for quite some time what differentiates people and people's cultures and their perspective in life. It's not the color of their skin, it's the cultural choices they make (the "read a book part" and not begging in the street for some easy gains), if people want to call me bigoted/racist so be it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- throwaway-hn123 10y agoIt says so much about HN that you won't get banned for being a racist fuck, but anyone who does call you out will.
- jedmeyers 10y ago
- teen 10y agoWhy would you factor out local cost of living when comparing incomes? For the wealthy, a high cost of living is a choice to live where they want.
- flamedoge 10y agoIt does make a few differences, ie. plan to save a lot and cash out at lower CoL places.
- gph 10y ago>For the wealthy, a high cost of living is a choice to live where they want. To an extent. I think some of them might not mind living in less expensive rural areas if they didn't need to be in proximity to their workplace or common areas of business. We aren't exclusively talking ultra-wealthy billionaires here, I imagine the article is mostly concerned with the more common wealthy upper-middle class workers like programmers, doctors, etc.
- lern_too_spel 10y agoBecause then you can show that controlling for location, Asians don't make more than whites. Asians who live in high cost of living places or low cost of living places make the same as whites living in the same locations despite having more education. This analysis is a rebuttal to the argument that Asian median income as a whole being higher than white median income implies that America is a post-racial society where working hard will result in equal reward regardless of race.
- home_boi 10y agoHas no one done a study on the amount of time each race spends studying? It seems to be a very easy data to collect and could help us draw an actual conclusion.
- randyrand 10y agoBut when you factor out how many more times Asian parents tell their kids to study, they actually study about the same. /s
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vidoc 10y agoI'm always amazed at how obsessed certain people are with "race" (aka ethnicity) in this country. I'm very well aware of the tough racial history and I'm not saying that kind of ethnical stats shouldn't be made, but frankly, shouldn't we be talking about social classes instead? This last presidential election was a great display of what I am talking about from both side. While one side was demonizing non-WASP, the other side banked its whole strategy on the fact that african-americans would surely vote for them (which is, when you think about it, basically saying that most people's vote cannot be predicted as they may flip/flop and are usually 50/50 +/- 5%, except for african-americans of course ...). And of course the next day, they were blamed responsible for the defeat.
- dnprock 10y ago"Asians are really not better than whites" maybe, that should be the title.
- randyrand 10y agoAnother huge flaw: COL is not at all a sunk cost like this article has you believe; places with higher COL are generally better places to live. it's actually is a good indicator for the hard to quantify value in living one place over another. In other words, you can't just blindly factor it out and call it a day. There is real value in living in San Francisco vs bumblefuck. It's the whole reason people want to live there in the first place despite it's higher COL! In turn for your extra COL, you generally get access to nearby airports for travel, access to good jobs, a variety of career choices, a wide assortment of options for food and social nightlife, etc. These things have real value. You pay for this value. you can't just blindly factor out COL.
- ivthreadp110 10y agoI agree about the logic flaws in this article. As someone who works with one of the largest public college systems in the USA, yes, URM and Non_URM students do tend to give off the impression that asian americans fair better, and yes it is an illusion- however, focusing on ethnicity is a mistake when focusing on students who's parents also went to college- and pre-existing socio-economic status. Asia is much father away then mexico or what have you- it costs more to come here from asian countries then it does from hispanic contries on travel distance alone. I don't like this article, I also don't like the URM/NON-URM status that school systems make based on ethnicity alone. There are many fields in which non_urm (meaning not white or asian) preform better- and they call these negative gaps. A gap is an ABS there is no -Gap. Pardon my spelling mistakes.
- ivthreadp110 10y agoThe illusion of it all is that you can measure based on "ethnicity" instead of something that matters more... such as being a first generation college student- being a first generation immigrant to the states- if you are eligible for PELL status or not. It's silly that we, the USA, still use ethnicity over socio-economic background as a measure to compare student success. When in all reality- ethnicity does not matter- it's about the culture and family you are raised in. No ethnicity is innately better then any other one. Culturally some might be more focused on education- and as a country, the United States is losing that culture because instead of focusing on future generations we focus on ethnicity and dumb shit.
- ivthreadp110 10y agoThis is a utter shit article- I work with these root statistics on a daily basis- yes they are bent based on what he is trying to rrove. It's the flaw having a theory then making the data prove it instead of looking at the data and coming up with a theory. Keep bending the data fool
- ivthreadp110 10y agoEveryone can bend data. I work with the raw data of this kind of thing. Sure his graphs and charts are "right" but they're bent data. As a data scientist we don't cook the books. It's the readers of our results who decide to Cook them.
- ivthreadp110 10y agohttps://calstate.edu/highschool https://calstate.edu/highschool On the second tab you can see demographics.
- ivthreadp110 10y agoFull list of highschools: https://csudata.calstate.edu/highschool/school-list?pagestyle=hs https://csudata.calstate.edu/highschool/school-list?pagestyl...