3 ms·
Mad respect to Mez, but I was disappointed by something here. He devotes a very thoughtful paragraph to the algorithmic complexity of intelligence augmentation,
by samatman 10y ago
Mad respect to Mez, but I was disappointed by something here. He devotes a very thoughtful paragraph to the algorithmic complexity of intelligence augmentation, then cites Intel achieving n^2 improvements in transistor density in linear time as being non-transcendental.
He's correct, but the reason is obscured: Moore's Law appears to be following a logistic curve, and is leveling out as we speak. If it wasn't, the compounding interest of quadratic transistor increases over linear time could well lead to a (relatively) hard takeoff at the point where a single chip contains a human brain's worth of calculating ability. Granted that concept (a brain's worth of computation) is hand-wavey and poorly defined: but the point is that if 20n's Intel processor has one brain's worth, than 20n+1 has two, and 20n+2 has four, and so on.
- ThomPete 10y agoMoores Law is important but it's not more important than the emerging complexity of connected networks and devices IMO.
- Hondor 10y agoAnd all the CPUs in the world have a 20 billion brains worth. Despite the large number of transistors, they're still not organized in a way which makes them intelligent, no matter how many times you multiply them.
- tim333 10y ago>Granted that concept (a brain's worth of computation) is hand-wavey and poorly defined It's not that bad. There are two measures - function equivalence in devices using optimal algorithms - things like Siri, self driving cars and secondly trying to simulate a copy of the neurons in the brain similar to the Blue Brian project. The numbers are roughly 100 teraflops for the first case, about 1000x that for the second. Moores law gets all the press coverage but the more interesting thing is the amount of computing per dollar keeps doubling, did so long before Moore and probably will for a while yet. https://ourworldindata.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Calculations-per-Second-per-1000-Exponential-Growth-of-Computing-for-110-years-Kurzweil.png https://ourworldindata.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Calcul...