2 ms·
> The government forced soap manufacturers to remove from soap the thing that makes them work for these purposes: phosphates. Did it? https://www.theguardian.
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
> The government forced soap manufacturers to remove from soap the thing that makes them work for these purposes: phosphates.
Did it?
https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/proctor-gamble-remove-phosphates-laundry-soap https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/proctor-gam...
> But P&G already stopped using phosphates in laundry detergent sold across the US in the early 1990s as part of a voluntary commitment from the American Cleaning Institute, an industry group of which the company is a member. It also removed phosphates from its detergents sold in the Europe several years ago.
And while Mr. Tucker offers good reasons to remove flow restrictors from showers - domestic water use is only 2% of the nation's total - he doesn't tell us why phosphates were removed from soap, just complains that his clothes are dirty (big ol' [citation needed] on that, by the way.)
Apparently phosphates damage the environment, leading to algal blooms and fish die-offs. But it's fine. I'll gladly read Mr. Tucker's article blaming the government for his inability to go fishing or swimming if phosphates are added back to laundry detergent.
He also blames "the government", a nebulous entity, but only seventeen states seem to have banned soap manufacturers from using phosphates in soap. An odd tack for someone who I would expect to be pro-states'-rights: http://www.npr.org/2010/12/15/132072122/it-s-not-your-fault-your-dishes-are-still-dirty http://www.npr.org/2010/12/15/132072122/it-s-not-your-fault-...
- mhneu 10y ago>An odd tack for someone who I would expect to be pro-states'-rights From the rest of your comment I'd guess you already know this, but organizations like these have no particular affinity for the rights of states. Conservative-funded organizations are only pro-states'-rights when it advances their other agendas -- usually identity politics around race (where "states' rights" has been a dog whistle since Nixon and Reagan), and economically where states with different regulations can promote a race to the bottom that benefits corporations and the wealthy (Delaware's rules on corporations are a good example).
- mikestew 10y ago(big ol' [citation needed] on that, by the way.) You won't get one because it's bullshit. My front loader using cold water with modern detergents gets my clothes clean just fine. Covered in mud from a trail run? Clean. Working at the dog shelter, dog poops his kennel, walks in it, jumps on me when I walk in? Dog shit on pants: gone. Blood on the sheets from that "tragic accident"? Lily white after one wash (I wish the same could be said for my soul). Does it get clothes as clean as back in the "good old days" of phosphates, hot water, and top-loaders? Damned if I know, that was twenty years ago and my memory's not that good. And neither is the memory of the author when it comes to such subtle things as how clean your clothes were two decades ago.