5 ms·
Quantifying the Cost of Sprawl (2013)
- shawnee_ 10y agoAnd compact development produces on average about 10 times more tax revenue per acre. So the author of this article is trying to sell this approach based on the "benefit" of tax revenue per acre? Is that (should that be) the primary goal of a city's design... to squeeze out as many tax dollars as possible from every square inch of space? The main problem with compact development (my observation) is the HOA fees that tend to be baked into owning in one of these "compact" developments. These fees are very often ostentatious and do not map out to actual costs of building or maintaining shared infrastructure "compactly". And let's not even get into the pitfalls of CCRs that disallow pet ownership, fine members for paint colors, etc.
- sxates 10y agoPlenty of low-density suburban neighborhoods have similar HOAs and restrictions, though at a lower $/sq.ft. than a downtown high-rise.
- davidw 10y agoA city should be financially solvent, and a lot of them are not, long term. http://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme/ http://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme/
- emodendroket 10y agoHOAs enjoy all kinds of wild quasi-governmental powers without the same level of accountability as a real government; I think they're a tremendous downside to ownership in both condos and new developments.
- ocschwar 10y agoA city shouldn't strive to maximize tax revenue, but they should definitely strive to make sure the revenue is at least a few cents higher than the cost of maintaining the roads, water and sewer hookups, police & fire, et cetera. For many cities it's simply a matter of selling a few parking lots to developers and letting them put up condo complexes. Old timers will scream and yell about the loss of parking, but those condos will mean the water mains get maintained on time.
- trome 10y agoWhy would you live in a HOA controlled area? At least in the Pacific Northwest they are viewed as scum of the earth, and are not a common burden most people will encounter.
- rootusrootus 10y agoLeft out of this equation is perhaps the most important number to buyers: price. All of these numbers show us how much more efficient it is to serve households in urban environments, and how much more tax revenue it yields for governments -- but that is not passed along to buyers. For example, the suburban house that I paid $350K for 15 miles away from downtown would cost a $1M if I wanted a similarly appointed condo in the city. And that excludes the additional taxes, building fees (which can be substantial), and parking costs.
- cma 10y agoHow so? Maybe other aspects of city properties are desirable and drive up the price, but the efficiency gains still apply and without them it would be even more expensive. Maybe you could get an even bigger house than your suburb one in a third world country for even cheaper.
- rootusrootus 10y agoA good friend of mine lives in a 1200sf condo in the city, and he pays almost $500/month in HOA fees. Isn't that a good proxy for efficiency? Unless the association is making a tidy profit. That's a bit more than my ongoing expected maintenance costs for this house are.
- someguydave 10y agoOften HOAs are nearly mandatory. Local governments love it when HOAs provide services (through extra fees) while the government also collects full taxes on the property.
- et1337 10y agoI think the idea is to get a smaller house in the city. I've been reading a blog called McMansion Hell lately (highly highly recommended), and it has a great article detailing some of the pitfalls of large, affordable suburban homes [1]. [1] http://www.mcmansionhell.com/post/150597521816/mcmansions-101-revisited-aesthetics-aside-why http://www.mcmansionhell.com/post/150597521816/mcmansions-10...
- emodendroket 10y agoI think if you think about it it is obvious that tax revenues per square foot are going to be much higher for a many-story apartment complex than for a single-family home. Less than clear is who would be compelled by that information to move to a city center. I am a bit surprised to see tax revenues for a Walmart are lower than even the home; it seems to me like that would be a more interesting angle to explore.
- ocschwar 10y agoWell, that was written more to say that municipal governments should allow more apartment complexes, than to say you should move in to them. That said, if you prefer your 2 acres far out of town, be aware that the bill for sprawl can come due in the worst possible ways. It's pretty nasty to find out that since your city hall couldn't afford to keep up with repairs on your sewer main, they didn't. It's especially bad to find out by a raw seweage backup in your cellar. Perhaps that would compel you?
- emodendroket 10y agoIf you really live in the hinterlands you probably have a septic tank and a well, and besides that similar issues can crop up in cities too.
- ocschwar 10y agoThen you're liable to live where fire department coverage is nominal (as in, it exists, but the drive to your house is so far there's no point.)
- emodendroket 10y agoThat's not necessarily true. Have you spent much time in the suburbs? Plenty of places you could live where you don't have city water or sewers but the town fire department isn't very far away.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sAuronas 10y agoExcept it doesn't... developers skip the urban infill for the burbs because the gross costs (entitlement fees) are way higher. Sure, it cost less per lot for urban infill when you only consider lot costs for sewer, water, etc (in-tract) but older municipalities are so fucked with decaying tax bases and overhead that they try to extract it all in taxes and fees (mellow-roos and in-lieus) that they make single family development cost-prohibitive anywhere but the outermost rural areas. To compare condo to single-family cost is just stupid: the cost of building multiple units is - only - justifiable when the prices are sufficiently high: in urban areas that are already built up. First world problems.
- trome 10y agoEh, utilities aren't the main showstopper, zoning is. So much land in cities is zoned for 2 to 3 story single family detached homes, and upzoning it after homes are built on that land is hard to do, and its even harder to find a block that is all willing to sell to one developer. Hence why the edges of gullies and ravines become where high density buildings are built, since low density housing is very hard to uproot. What this causes is more low density urban infill, which is much more destructive. Where one older home was before, 2 cheap as chips 3000sqft concreteboard boxes will be built as cheaply and quickly as possible. Builder errors like forgetting to put eaves on the house will be fixed by nailing an overhang on afterwards, only to leak 4 or 5 years down the line. If high density development was easier in urban cores, there would be much less incentive to build shoddy detached housing. As it stands there is a ton of pent up demand, and tons of zoning to block development.
- sAuronas 10y agoZoning is not a show-stopper everywhere. You'd be surprised to know that many places you can develop much higher densities "by right." Phoenix, for example, has the density potential of Brooklyn near its downtown (just south) but it's solely ramshackle, chicken-wired single family at the moment. Downtown Oakland could be 100 times as dense as it is currently. Zoning, per se, isn't the issue there but the people who will fight it at all costs (the developer's). You could rezone all of West LA to Manhattan density tomorrow and you'd get nowhere... People will fight it. You're right, I oversimplified because I was being facetious. I used to be a developer of both sprawl (Toll Bros and KB Home) and infill. I am bitter about how we live in the US. No one should be paying $500/SF to live in Oakland when there are empty lots and single-story strip malls occupying space for high rises. High-density development is no more difficult than suburban development from a technical matter. It is a market problem. The costs get driven up arbitrarily at times by bad actors.