6 ms·
My New Year’s Resolution – read a research paper every weekday
- jmnicholson 10y agoYou should try writing these on authorea.com (get DOI and permanent archival). Basically, turning them into official pieces of open post-publication peer review. Could cross-post to your blog too still!
- mtw 10y agoI don't know about CompSci research. However I do http://outcomereference.com/ http://outcomereference.com/ which is just a side-project and read about 2-3 medical research papers everyday and the biggest challenge is open access to papers. It is possible to find the PDFs on various research sites but the vast majority is costly (avg $40 per paper). Not sure if there is free & open access for CompSci research?
- Mathnerd314 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sci-Hub https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sci-Hub
- imranq 10y agoI like the idea of scientifically vetting foods, but as you said it might be hard coming up with a balanced viewpoint if you are not considering all the research. Also might be helpful to consider the impact factor of each paper you are citing.
- matt4077 10y agoLet me get my smart-ass instinct out of the way first: journals have impact factors, not papers :) But it doesn't really matter because it's a somewhat-empty vanity-metric anyway. For assessing clinical trials (and aggregating their results) the Cochrane collaboration is probably the gold standard. Here's something I found on their method to evaluate trial quality: http://www.bmj.com/content/343/bmj.d5928 http://www.bmj.com/content/343/bmj.d5928
- fanf2 10y agoA lot of CS papers are available on http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/ http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nl 10y agoIn CompSci it's pretty rare for there not to be open access versions of a major paper. Off the top of my head there have been a few in Nature but outside that almost everything ends up as open access.
- jorgemf 10y agoYou can read one paper a day, but I am not sure you can understand one paper a day. At least for me during my PhD I spent more than a full-time day to completely understand papers that were interesting for my research.
- rubidium 10y agoI'd state it with a bit more nuance. From my experience in physics: You can read a paper in 15-30 minutes and get the main points and contributions. For good papers, you can spend multiple days to really understand the paper. And for really good papers you can spends months to completely understand them, then extend them, and then publish your dissertation.
- kejaed 10y agoReminds me of the 3 pass approach in the paper, "How to read a paper" http://blizzard.cs.uwaterloo.ca/keshav/home/Papers/data/07/paper-reading.pdf http://blizzard.cs.uwaterloo.ca/keshav/home/Papers/data/07/p...
- avian 10y agoI'm slowly finishing up my PhD and I tend to agree with you. However, he will probably be reading quite a different selection of papers than what you encounter during a PhD. In my experience, time required varies quite a lot between papers and authors. If you take a paper from, say, top 1% (or 0.1%) of papers published on some broad topic, you can probably read through it once and get some relatively good understanding of what the author was trying to say (and very likely enough to write a short re-cap). This is definitely not true for the remaining 99% of the published scientific literature. At one point I had the idea of keeping up with my field of research by setting up Google Scholar alerts. This resulted in about 1 paper per 2-3 days that seemed to be worth studying based on the title and abstract. Still at that rate I found it quite impossible to keep up with all the content that dredged up.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- PikelEmi 10y agoJust read or read AND understand ?
- djhworld 10y agoI've been reading Adrian's blog for about a year now, I honestly I don't know how he finds the time.
- gburdell 10y agoI would say that he's insane, but his blog already summarizes a research paper every weekday. I had thrown around the idea of doing this with my own field, but I found that it took me the better part of a day to really understand the paper, much less commit a summary to prose.
- pknerd 10y agoThis should be a movement. I will try to read at 1 paper per month. Good enough for a beginner.
- drdre2001 10y agoYou might be interested in Fermart's Library:http://fermatslibrary.com http://fermatslibrary.com
- saeranv 10y agoQuestion: What are the selection criteria people use to determine which papers to read. I went through a period where I tried to get in the habit of reading research papers regularly. Two issues I found that lead me to eventually dropping this: (1) At least in my industry (generative architecture & building performance modeling) it's frustrating how often papers don't include technical details, and resort simply to a high-level overviews of implementation and go straight to detailing their outcome. I don't learn much from such papers. (2) Low return of value of simply just reading the paper. I went through a period where I tried to read a paper everyday. By the end of this period I had a massive stack of highlighted, and annotated research papers I kept in a folder on my desk. And that folder has remained there untouched to this day. So I find there is low value in simply consuming research, and the key for me at least is to actually struggle through and implement the research I read. Which is why point (1) is key for me. I'm inspired by your post though, I want to start getting back into a slightly modified version of this. Identify research papers with algorithms I can play with/experiment - and then implement it, aiming for something like a paper per week or so? This process means I won't be able to do a paper per day, but it'll be a lot more valuable/interesting to me. This calls for a new git repo...
- jonwachob91 10y ago>resort simply to a high-level overviews of implementation and go straight to detailing their outcome Those don't sound like research papers but articles... What Journal(s) are you finding these papers in?
- saeranv 10y agoIs it only a research paper if it is published in a journal? What about conference papers? Here's an example I was reading recently which doesn't go into much detail: http://www.ibpsa.org/proceedings/asim2012/0097.pdf http://www.ibpsa.org/proceedings/asim2012/0097.pdf from the International Building Performance Simulation Association (IBPSA) conference.
- tnecniv 10y ago
- LunaSea 10y agoAre there any good feeds of newly written machine learning research papers that are worth reading and that is regularly updated?
- urlwolf 10y agoI agree wih the rest : this is too hard. Some papers will take a long time to grasp. More so after we have been conditioned to read things fast on he web.
- tps5 10y agoYou're right, that does sound crazy.
- egl2016 10y agoAndrew Ng on this topic: "...if you seriously study half a dozen papers a week and you do that for two years, after those two years you will have learned a lot." http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/05/13/andrew-ng_n_7267682.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/05/13/andrew-ng_n_7267682...
- codeddesign 10y agoAnyone know of good online libraries to find research papers?
- Cd00d 10y agohttps://arxiv.org/ https://arxiv.org/
- fanf2 10y agohttp://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/ http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/
- anonymousDan 10y agoDon't bother trawling through libraries. Look at the list of top conferences in your field and just go through the proceedings of those (e.g. for systemsy conferences look at the list given in the article as a good starting point). You should be able to get free versions of most papers you find through Google.
- kakaorka 10y agosci-hub?
- petercooper 10y agoI wonder if a higher level equivalent of this could be to read a full IEEE article every day (from the right publications, of course), since these often seem to be more accessible writeups of academic papers anyway and a lot of the hard work of curating and picking out the key details has been done.
- arnarbi 10y agoSpend some time on context. Reading papers in isolation maybe makes you appreciate the idea that it presents, but understanding how that idea came about and what alternative ideas it replaced or subsumed primes you for extending or applying it. For that it's perhaps more valuable to scan more background material loosely, rather than just adding today's references to your reading list. Also it's very helpful to pay attention to names and affiliations when doing this. Another pitfall I've had with regular reading like "a paper a day/week" is not to discard papers fast enough. Often the abstract either oversells the results, or the details are simply too obvious to you to learn anything new from them. Learn to recognize "weak" (to you) papers early and skim through the rest of it quickly or look for better sources on the topic. I'd suggest aiming to understand an idea a week, which maybe involves reading 2-4 papers, and skimming 15-20 more, plus background material in textbooks and Wikipedia. Doing that in 8-12 hours would already be pretty efficient.
- orthoganol 10y ago> If you like the idea of being exposed to more research and cutting-edge ideas over 2017... Why not just read abstracts? It doesn't seem like his goal is more than "Let's see what people are up to." In the context of AI / ML / DL, white papers were useful for me when I had a very specific task in mind and wanted to see the cutting edge approaches. Outside of that, I wasted untold hours I wish I had back reading white papers because they seemed important. I don't think I really got anything useful at the end of the day, in terms of advancing my projects. I also believe some deep learning papers completely exaggerate their results while being intentionally vague on how they implemented, and I wish had those hours back too trying to replicate. I don't know, I disagree with the notion that it's inherently good to read a bunch of white papers. Better I think is work on your project, and when there are gaps go searching for papers.
- Girlang 10y agoPlease come back next year and tell us something about each of the ~260 papers you've read. Until then, I'll tell you about my New Year's Resolution: To Cure Cancer, to bring World Piece, and to win the Nobel Prize.
- mohitmun 10y agoThis is a good stackexchange thread http://cstheory.stackexchange.com/questions/1168/what-papers-should-everyone-read http://cstheory.stackexchange.com/questions/1168/what-papers...
- Joky 10y agoIn my field (Software), I find more profitable to me to watch one 40 min video from a conference rather than trying to understand a paper where the author had to compress all the information in a silly 10 pages limit from a random conference. As an author it is amazing how I feel I can communicate my work more efficiently, and with pedagogy in a talk with slides (or in a blog post maybe) than in the constraints of an academic paper.
- twoslide 10y agoYes, I'm planning to cut back too. - An academic
- acaloiar 10y agoI'm not sure that one can derive significant value from reading a research paper per day. Great research is not easily grokked or appreciated upon first read. I think one would derive far more value from reading a single paper for an entire week.