4 ms·
This paper never claimed to be an independent report on the study. For the actual report, you have to look elsewhere (not sure if it's freely available). This p
by the_af 10y ago
This paper never claimed to be an independent report on the study. For the actual report, you have to look elsewhere (not sure if it's freely available). This paper is explicitly a report by one of the parties involved, and a piece of advocacy for FP. Paul Hudak (RIP) was well-known in the Haskell community. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Hudak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Hudak
Regardless, the scorecard itself -- showing Haskell to be one of the winners -- was written by the review panel and not by the author of this paper. Those are the cold facts!
Two more interesting facts:
1- The experiment itself was not designed by the FP community, but was an actual (if simplified) system designed by the Navy. No constraints or requirements were tailored to make things easier for FP; in fact most participants were unfamiliar with FP.
2- A second Haskell prototype was written by an independent programmer, unconnected to the paper's author, who was unfamiliar with Haskell and had to learn it before completing the assignment. I find this very interesting.