3 ms·
I read the article and skimmed the full study and was left scratching my head: - What exactly do they mean by 'Competitiveness'? - Why so much focus on labour
by rahimnathwani 10y ago
I read the article and skimmed the full study and was left scratching my head:
- What exactly do they mean by 'Competitiveness'?
- Why so much focus on labour costs, when manufacturing cost is increasingly driven by large capital investments (especially in China, where low interest rates and government encouragement have expanded capital investments for years)
- Why all the talk about R&D expenditure. Is that really a driver of manufacturing competitiveness (whatever that means) or manufacturing output?
- How do they expect (on page 46) China's consumption to rise to 46% of GDP by 2025, if GDP will rise at 6.5% per year during the period? Such a shift would require consumption to go up by ~10% per year.
- maxerickson 10y agoHow do they expect (on page 46) China's consumption to rise to 46% of GDP by 2025, if GDP will rise at 6.5% per year during the period? Such a shift would require consumption to go up by ~10% per year. Perhaps a relative reduction in exports? When costs go up in China the goods that can be profitably produced elsewhere tend to increase.
- ThomPete 10y agoThe focus on labour cost is, I believe, because China have been suppressing it's own currency to stay competitive. But it's just a guess as I am only reading through the article and the study as we speak.
- netheril96 10y ago> because China have been suppressing it's own currency to stay competitive. Had been. China's currency is facing pressure to depreciate nowadays, and the Chinese government is having a hard choice between propping the value of CNY and preserving its reserves of dollars.
- edblarney 10y ago"Why so much focus on labour costs" Because the other things you mentioned - i.e. 'capital investments' - China does not have a huge advantage in. Yes, they have 'government participation' but US companies have access to capital, low interest rates, yada yada.
- bzbarsky 10y agoChina is likely going to have one or more of the following going on: 1) Less GDP growth than the 6.5% prediction. 2) Less consumption growth as a fraction of GDP (hence deepening imbalances and higher corporate debt levels). 3) Massive wealth/income transfers to the household sector to allow for a rise in consumption. You're right that without #3 it's pretty unlikely that consumption will rise as much as that article claims.