3 ms·
> I always wondered why nobody used UDP for bulk data transfer 1) Bulk data transfer doesn't work over UDP. There is no flow control whatsoever with UDP and n
by user5994461 10y ago
> I always wondered why nobody used UDP for bulk data transfer
1) Bulk data transfer doesn't work over UDP.
There is no flow control whatsoever with UDP and no guarantee, it sends stuff without distinction between a 56k uplink and a 10Gigabit LAN. The packet loss and lack of reliability are atrocious when you send non negligible amount of data.
2) You'd need to create a protocol on top of UDP to handle the basics (controlflow/error/retransmission), that's equivalent to re-inventing TCP. Don't re-invent your own TCP, just use TCP ;)
- cthalupa 10y ago>1) Bulk data transfer doesn't work over UDP. Tell that to all of the people that use TsunamiUDP to do bulk data transfer. It uses TCP as a control protocol, but the data transfer is all UDP.
- paulddraper 10y agoIt sounds like they would agree. Bulk data transfer doesn't work over UDP, but it can work over UDP and TCP.
- cthalupa 10y agoThe data transfer itself is happening over UDP.