4 ms·
The biggest problem with taxing copyright is how to value it, which ranges from wildly arbitrary to completely impossible. The most rational way would be to ta
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
The biggest problem with taxing copyright is how to value it, which ranges from wildly arbitrary to completely impossible.
The most rational way would be to tax licensing revenue, but that makes it a non-solution to your problem because if nobody knows who to license the copyright from then nobody is licensing it and there is no revenue to tax.
It also seems rather unlikely that if you can't stop a completely irrational copyright term extension, you could nonetheless bring about a copyright tax on the same people. You're more likely to be able to prevent further copyright term extensions.
And there is a well known solution to the orphan works problem, which is to require copyright registration after some period (e.g. after every 14 years).
- marcus_holmes 10y agoyeah, these are good points. If you're taxing revenue then what do you do in the case of person A who licences the copyright (for nothing) to person B who then makes a living from it. All those loopholes... But it does seem that attaching revenue to a law makes it more likely to get passed. "Screw Disney, we can alleviate budget problems with this..."
- Spivak 10y ago> taxing copyright is how to value it, which ranges from wildly arbitrary to completely impossible. It doesn't have to be impossible, you just have to create a system where the copyright holder values it for you. Imagine you decided to have a 1% copyright tax. To maintain your copyright you pay the government some amount of money. That amount will be extrapolated to determine the true value of the copyright. So if you pay 10 million then you get a 1 billion valuation. Here's the catch. In order to incentivize copyright holders to value their IP accurately anyone is allowed to purchase full ownership of the copyright at the value of their valuation. The holder can of course counter a purchase by paying more tax and you prevent predatory buying by requiring the money up front.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoConsider what you're doing to startups. You've created the next big thing but have little cash, someone shows up with a lowball offer and now you have to take it because you don't have the cashflow to pay the tax yet. There is also the political problem that you would be forcing artists to sell the rights to their art to the highest bidder, even if the highest bidder is their enemy, or a censor who would erase their public image by locking their work in a vault and never showing it to anyone.