6 ms·
As an Iraq War veteran myself I'm pretty sick of these stories being what get headlines and pages of coverage about military members. People read these pieces a
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
As an Iraq War veteran myself I'm pretty sick of these stories being what get headlines and pages of coverage about military members. People read these pieces and think it defines an entire generation of War Veterans. It doesn't. No hit on the authors, they all seem to be genuinely wanting to help/tell a compelling story - but I think it comes with some kind of fetish for war that they are trying to get in touch with. How about instead we talk about War Vets who are successful (or on their way)?
Here are a few of my personal friends:
Abraham Kamarck and Kevin Powell Army and Navy Vets. Founders True Made Foods:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/robindschatz/2016/04/20/mission-accomplished-how-two-ketchup-vetpreneurs-draw-strength-from-their-differences/#65963a00552a http://www.forbes.com/sites/robindschatz/2016/04/20/mission-...
Kim Jung and Emily Miller. Army Vets. Founders, Rumi Spice:
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/11/business/smallbusiness/a-start-up-turns-to-saffron-to-help-afghanistan-regrow.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/11/business/smallbusiness/a-s...
Mike Janke. Navy Vet (SEAL). Founder Silent Circle:
http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2012/10/silent_circle_mike_janke_s_iphone_app_makes_encryption_easy_governments.html http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2012/1...
...and there are thousands starting and running their own businesses, charities, churches, schools, working at googamafacesoft etc...none of them looking for special treatment or special recognition. It's a part of our story that most of us are proud of, but it's not everything.
We take care of our own as best we can, and people fall through the cracks. The issues with the care system for vets isn't perfect, but it also takes effort on the part of those who need help, and those who aren't willing to help themselves and take advantage of those programs are the ones you hear about.
So lets stop treating our vets like they need special treatment - good or bad.
- bootload 10y ago"I'm pretty sick of these stories being what get headlines and pages of coverage about military members. ... No hit on the authors, they all seem to be genuinely wanting to help/tell a compelling story - but I think it comes with some kind of fetish for war that they are trying to get in touch with." There is truth to what you say. The biggest issue I see, isn't the story so much trauma, trauma and war are hand maidens in history, it's how main-stream western society is shielded from the military. There is no common experience. Period. That's the bigger story. The author is C. J. Chivers, USMC (Capt. Retd.), so yeah, ^the fetish for war^ is strong. So strong, he had to quit for the sake of those around him. [0] [0] http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a37838/end-of-war-1015/ http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a37838/end-of-war-1015/
- AndrewKemendo 10y agomain-stream western society is shielded from the military. There is no common experience. Period. That's the bigger story. We talk about this a lot and it's an odd topic. On the one hand it's great that western countries have the luxury of having so few impacts from wars that many don't even know that the US still has 8,400 military personnel in Afghanistan. On the other hand it makes the population really not give a shit about issues surrounding formal war or it's personal impacts, so they end up just letting politicians slide on stuff.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> it makes the population really not give a shit about issues surrounding formal war Soldiers are between truck drivers and lawyers. More tactile than, and similarly skilled as, most of them. The luxury of the first world is the population's ability to ignore dying soldiers.
- accountface 10y agoChivers surprised me. I set out to stereotype him as some gun fetishist and walked away from his book about the AK-47 with a full sense that small-arms proliferation is one of the worst things to happen in human history.
- wyager 10y agoThat seems like a strange conclusion to reach. Humanity is per-capita less violent than ever, despite probably the highest per-capita small arms density in history. My suspicion is that the techniques available for individuals to kill each other has little impact on their proclivity to kill each other. Of course, that says nothing about the impact of increasingly effective large-scale weapons (nuclear/biological/chemical) on the proclivity of organizations like governments to kill people.
- bootload 10y ago"Humanity is per-capita ^less violent^ than ever," Relative, like standing at the side of the road instead of in it. One reason I never talk about stuff like this is ppl who intellectualise rather than show any understanding of emotional response.
- ryanmarsh 10y ago> We take care of our own as best we can, and people fall through the cracks This statement disgusts me. I struggled immensely transitioning from combat to civilian life. Nobody helped until years later I got lucky and someone referred me to a preacher who was also a therapist. The VA threw pills at myself and my brothers. Some of them are dead now. Some took their own lives on purpose, others on accident living dangerously. Some have spent time in prison for turning violent. I count myself incredibly lucky that I didn't kill anyone and wind up in prison. I'm so upset by your comment. It's so wrong. Killing people, getting killed, being constantly in threat of mortal danger, these things break our brains. We do not take care of our own the best we can. We do a shit job of it IMO.
- james-watson 10y agoTell me, friend, how does a group of people enforce their rights within a country against those who wish to deny those rights? ISIS wants a global Islamic caliphate, along with a Caliph at its head and Sharia law. They want this in the US, Europe, and every other country on the planet. They do not negotiate, because they believe they carry out the will of an omnipotent deity. And most importantly, they will brutally slaughter anyone who stands in their way. So, how do we defend our rights to a different way of life, against those who would kill us for it? Oh, and a cursory glance at history would be educational. Pacifism is a great idea, until it isn't.
- mereWords 10y agoHistory, history, history. Observed as an apparition conjured in a vacuum, ISIS really looks like such a beast, that no one could have created it or prevented it, right? It seems like such an alien organization, that it must have always existed, but we know that's not true. But let's suspend disbelief, cast aside rational thought, grab a gun and do something, because something like this requires direct action before it's too late! Not really. It's just smoke an mirrors. The country was deliberately destroyed for no reason. Iraq has been transformed into the mutilated free fire zone it is, because there was a good excuse for it, at the time, and there might never have been a better chance like that, to get away with destroying Iraq like there was at that moment. So now panic about ISIS, right? Panic about the bad guys. Let people initiate opportunistic wars in 2003, so we can panic about the results in 2016? Doesn't something about that seem a little odd?
- specialist 10y ago...and those who aren't willing to help themselves... It's simple. Help people help themselves, help those who can't. People with diseases often can't help themselves. Whether its caused by drugs, war, poverty, assault, cancer, whatever. Because they're sick. And people do all sorts of stupid things when they're sick. So lets stop treating our vets like they need special treatment - good or bad. Tough love and neglect is a suboptimal strategy for treating PTSD. My bestie served, he was harmed; he was fine until he wasn't. He deserves whatever consideration we can offer. I'm glad you and most others weren't harmed that way. Have some empathy for those not so fortunate.
- steverb 10y agoI think it's telling that all of your examples of war vets who are successful are officers. As a vet myself, I suspect the percentages of officers who have trouble acclimating is markedly lower than that of enlisted.