5 ms·
> Economists claim to make precise what is vague, and are convinced that economics is superior to all other disciplines, because the objectivity of money enabl
by tomrod 10y ago
> Economists claim to make precise what is vague, and are convinced that economics is superior to all other disciplines, because the objectivity of money enables it to measure historical forces exactly, rather than approximately.
Economist here. Maybe some economists make this very bold, presumptive claim. But I'll be honest, money very rarely enters into the paradigm; rather resource allocation and maximizing utility are the common approach. But then again, I didn't focus solely on financial economics.
The draw for me wasn't mathematical complexity, it was the ability to model behavioral interactions I witnessed on a daily basis. And I'll be honest--it is so much fun! The conception, the data collection, the validation of theory.
Anyhow, I now work as a data scientist where I use the theories of economics and the methods of econometrics (especially game theory considerations) to really move the ball on our strategy and our marketing. I enjoy the process a lot and love seeing economists entering the field. Statisticians and economists make a potent combination.
- soVeryTired 10y ago>resource allocation and maximizing utility are the common approach. Utility maximisation has always struck me as a horrible way to do modelling. In most cases your results must depend heavily on the form of utility function you choose. And you always have to make a choice since utility functions are unobservable.
- acjohnson55 10y agoI guess it is, if you seek analytic solutions to problems. But I personally found the concept utility to be absolutely enlightening as a way of thinking about individual and societal dynamics.
- smallnamespace 10y ago> And you always have to make a choice since utility functions are unobservable. If the utility function isn't provided to you directly, then you should infer the functional form from the data with a reasonable prior, and use sampling techniques to show the uncertainty in your answer due to uncertainty in the utility function. There's nothing wrong with utility functions as a model sense they are exactly dual to any 'reasonable' choice function, meaning the space they model is the same. If you find them mathematically inconvenient, then you can use choice functions directly, but raw choice functions are usually not very helpful for modeling or predicting anything at all.
- spangry 10y agoI guess the follow up question to this is: what superior alternative do you propose we use for evaluating competing government policies?
- js8 10y agoI don't think we should ditch "utility" entirely but rather the idea people are actors that try to rationally maximize utility. One problem is of uncertainty (this was pointed out by Keynes) - people simply do not trade higher risk for higher profits, even if the mean value increases in the mathematical sense. Rather, they set a horizon of uncertainty. The other big problem is that utility is ill-defined for an individual. We are competitive beings and value many things for reasons that are related to how other people value them. This cannot be modeled within the theory of rational choice. (It's also somewhat related to the fact that supply-demand is not that great model.) In other words, we should augment the models to take the above issues (at least, IMHO those are the biggest problems but certainly not the only ones) into consideration.
- spangry 10y agoI agree. I think at this point even the most conventional academic economist would start giving you sideways glances if you asserted that people are always rational utility maximisers. It seems that most econometric modelling takes a top-down approach; implicitly making homogenising assumptions about the models 'atoms' (e.g. individuals, firms, states, countries etc.). I often wonder if the future of economic modelling is to be found in 'agent-based' models, where you start at the lowest level and aggregate up. This approach makes it possible to account for the effects of non-homogeneous actors and to also include 'non-rational' behaviours observed in experimental/behavioural economics. I feel that the other issue is how beginner-level economics is taught at university. I would agree that there's no practical way to teach economics to beginners without making a bunch of simplifying assumptions and presenting a bunch of simplified models for study (e.g. a perfectly competitive market). However, I think the problem is that insufficient effort (if any) is made to emphasise that these models do not really reflect reality, and are just 'toy models' to help you develop your analytical thinking. At best, in a real world context, understanding these models gives you an analytical framework for reasoning about whether some policy proposal is pointing in the right or wrong direction, though even that is a pretty fraught assertion. EDIT: I figured I'd address some of the comments below regarding randomised-controlled trials, since its related to agent-based modelling / simulation. Comments below have pretty much highlighted the crux of the problem with economics and public policy (albeit without comprehending the implications): barring the rare 'natural experiment', its virtually impossible to collect 'clean' data that allows comparison of different policies. It's true that RCTs are being run in a 'public-administration' context, and the idea is gaining popularity. Most notably, the UK government has run a bunch of RCTs on various things. But the crucial thing to note is that these RCTs are generally only run for 'low-stakes' issues. For instance, one of their RCTs involved varying the wording of their tax authority's "you haven't submitted a tax return" letter to determine what gets the highest compliance rate. How comfortable, from an ethical standpoint, would you feel running state-by-state RCTs to determine the best government healthcare policy? Particularly given that the outcome in some states will be higher levels of preventable death and permanent disability? I've chosen healthcare here because the connection between different policies and higher or lower rates of mortality is fairly direct. But for any other government policy (of any significance), you're generally looking at the same sort of stakes. It's just that the ultimate ill-effects of a bad policy are not immediately apparent, take a long time to unfold, and often only eventuate at the margins.
- tomrod 10y agoSure, just be sure to make assumptions known. Full rationality is a start, like linear model approximations are a good start, but eventually you do want to consider game theoretic concerns like bounded rationality, strategic behavior, etc.
- 8a 10y agoHow easy is it to get feedback? How quickly do you see results?
- tomrod 10y agoCan you expand a little bit on your question? I'll answer the best I understand your question. Being in industry with a large firm, feedback is very simple to get, I just go give a talk at an internal seminar. Results of a model or an implementation? Repeated observations/out of sample analysis often help with validating models. Implementation depends on the project.
- 8a 10y agoSure. I was trying to understand how hard it is for economists to make progress fast. I would imagine an economic model takes months to years to validate. I'm used to getting instant feedback from a computer when writing a program. Do you see the way economic models are built and tested improving or happening faster? Or is the main barrier not lack of diverse data points, but needing enough time to pass to stress the model.