3 ms·
> how to estimate the costs of a project properly – ought to be of interest to most people. In fact, the field repels all but connoisseurs of fanciful formal mo
by dmix 10y ago
> how to estimate the costs of a project properly – ought to be of interest to most people. In fact, the field repels all but connoisseurs of fanciful formal models.
Considering how bad humans are at planning most mid/large sized projects (let alone small ones), how much faith can we put into centralized planning on a large macro national scale?
Wouldn't the US be better off managing their local economies more directly? With differing assistance from the federal level. Rather than attempting to apply a model across a huge diverse national economy?
I feel like Canada (where I'm from) was much more capable at dealing with the crisis because we had a small more cohesive system and our localized issues are easily dealt with. I feel that starts to break down at a larger scale.
It would also make politics more predictable and less partisan where you don't have an economically 'forgotten' class of people disrupting national elections with protest votes.
The US was founded on federalist ideas and it seems it's decline from economic greatness (at least towards stagnant growth) has coincided with a divergence from those ideas to a top heavy centralized government, where the election of the president has grown to consume 90% of people's attention while only 10% as much is given to their congress, governors, state legislators, etc. A whole country complaining about 'Washington elites' as if it were a simple managerial issue for the next executive to solve rather than the result of a systemic shift in power toward the executive and federal governments that has gone unchallenged. Not to mention they seem to increasingly be given all the blame/praise for whether the economy functions well or not.
- edblarney 10y ago"I feel like Canada (where I'm from) was much more capable at dealing with the crisis because we had a small more cohesive system and our localized issues are easily dealt with. I feel that starts to break down at a larger scale." In Canada (where I'm from as well) - we definitely are not an more sophisticated than anywhere. Though your point about being 'smaller' I think is valid. We are simply very conservative, behaviourally. We generally have stricter rules about most things, our finance execs aren't as aggressive, people are much less likely to lie on application forms. We don't 'innovate' with finance, i.e. 'finding new ways to package crap mortgages to sell them as good' - that's an Anglo/American thing :) America is the 'land of the free' Canada has always been about 'order, stability and peaceful coexistence' - so it's a cultural thing that exhibits itself systematically. I should say one thing: we do have a wicked housing bubble in Toronto, and economists have been predicting demise for years, and it could very well happen if foreign buyers lose the ability to spend. A 'Chinese crash' combined with slightly higher interest rates - would put Toronto in a really, really dire situation. And we we can't blame economists for that one - the risks are clear.
- dmix 10y ago> A 'Chinese crash' combined with slightly higher interest rates - would put Toronto in a really, really dire situation. And we we can't blame economists for that one - the risks are clear. Agreed, I personally hope it results in a new common sense that housing is not the perfect silver bullet investment for everyone. And hopefully it results in more capital going to entrepreneurship and business, rather than 90% of people betting on stable corporate jobs and mortgage payments for their future financial independence. There are always economic tradeoffs made in bubbles, as capital is misplaced and used inefficiently, that are just as costly as the money lost on the actual investments. The banks are just as responsible for this too, I've heard ridiculous stories of middle class people getting offered million dollar mortgages while small/medium businesses are shutting down at a faster rate than new ones are being started.
- rhizome 10y agoCanada (where I'm from) was much more capable at dealing with the crisis because we had a small more cohesive system By my reading (http://www.nber.org/digest/dec11/w17312.html http://www.nber.org/digest/dec11/w17312.html), Canada hasn't had the US crises infect them due to centralization.