5 ms·
>We may finally get the promise of the 50's and 60's - less work and more leisure time thanks to technical advancements. We likely won't, because no one with t
by krapp 10y ago
>We may finally get the promise of the 50's and 60's - less work and more leisure time thanks to technical advancements.
We likely won't, because no one with the power to do so seems to be planning on making that future a reality. Automation exists to allow business owners to reap the benefits of labor without the burden of providing a living to human employees, not to free humans from the necessity of labor.
Barring some global socialist revolution and something like basic income, people made redundant by automation will still need jobs to survive, but automation means there will simply be fewer jobs available. The jobs that are available will be menial, low paying and high risk, because human labor will be practically worthless, as anything of value will already be done by machines.
Unfortunately, history shows that for the vast majority of people, it rarely works out the way you're looking forward to. For some, yes - for the well off and well connected, automation may lead to some sort of Eloi fantasy of intellectual opportunity and luxury. But everyone else is going to be left growing potatoes in the sewers.
Edit: obviously, there will need to be some people with the means to actually buy the goods that the robots will be making, but the efficiency of an automated economy means there needs to be far fewer such people, and they can be distributed globally.
- jodrellblank 10y agoEdit: obviously, there will need to be some people with the means to actually buy the goods that the robots will be making I don't see that as obvious. Why couldn't each company pay their robot employees a wage, and the robots buy the goods produced by the other companies and put them in a building for a few years before moving them to landfill. The exact same pattern as our current economy, which apparently holds itself up, but without needing humans to be involved.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Why couldn't each company pay their robot employees a wage, and the robots buy the goods produced by the other companies and put them in a building for a few years before moving them to landfill. By why would the companies do that. The robots are a distraction, the companies in that case are buying and storing the goods from other companies. Why would they do that?
- jodrellblank 10y agoI have no idea why they would do that, it just counters the claim "obviously, there will need to be some people with the means to actually buy the goods". If people are needed to buy goods, we can dodge around that by having the robots act like people and buy the same goods in the same patterns, and then there won't need to be people again. I have no idea how employees-buying-goods sustains our current economies (although I suspect it doesn't, and that they are inflationary, debt driven, and unsustainable).
- dragonwriter 10y agoPeople buy goods, often from companies other than their employer, because the goods provide utility to the people buying them. Why would robots, or more accurately the companies that own them, buy goods from other companies outside of those needed for the company's own business? There's no incentive to do that.
- jodrellblank 10y agoI saw your question and answered it, and you've asked the same thing again. I wasn't trying to conjour an incentive, I was literally countering the claim "people are obviously needed to buy goods" with the argument "robots could buy goods instead, it's not obvious that people are required for that". As to why, the inevitable conclusion is: Company A and Company B make goods which do not sell: both go out of business. Company A and Company B make goods which sell: they stay in business. In a world with no human labour, organizations which want to propagate their own existence will do what it takes, including trade agreements with other organizations. As long as the agreement to purchase each other's goods is backed by a chain of buyers ending in ever-growing and infinite fiat currency debt, it would be as stable as a real economy. And they could compete for each other's robot's coin to affect profits. And the question of "is it providing utility for a human" is ... utterly irrelevant.
- blakeyrat 10y agoSo THX-1138 basically.