4 ms·
Not to harp on the "technical interviews are disconnected from actual work!" angle too much, but I'm reminded of a comment from a thread about the creator of Ho
by Apocryphon 10y ago
Not to harp on the "technical interviews are disconnected from actual work!" angle too much, but I'm reminded of a comment from a thread about the creator of Homebrew failing a Google interview. Someone pointed out that it goes to show that it's possible to create widely-used software without an intimate knowledge of CS. I wonder if that's a disconcerting fact for some employers to grapple with.
- edblarney 10y agoTo be fair, the creator of a bit of software that is widely used may not necessarily be a good fit for Google. For many reasons. I find some creators put a lot of ego into their products, not that they are egoists so much, but doing something on your own can be emotionally challenging. I don't mean 'ego' in a negative way - just that when you are on your own you have to make so, so many decisions. APIs, compatibility, etc. etc. you're often a little overwhelmed, you often have to 'just do it' and 'go with your gut' in many areas. Which may or may not be a good practice/attitude for a Google employee. They might have a stronger sense of the 'outcome' (i.e. what it does) than the capacity for the underlying code. Maybe it 'does the job' but is poorly written? Which again, might not work in Google environment. ... and working on a very large team is night-and-day from working on your own. I think we all want to 'feel it is unfair' that such an important contributor somehow 'can't get a job at Google' ... maybe he's worthy, maybe not, but I can totally grasp someone mighn't be a good contributor at Google. Maybe it's easier to see it from a non-technical standpoint: it's often very difficult for founders of their own companies to get along in a place like Google. I think that's easier for us grasp. The same thing can apply in the technical domain.
- jorblumesea 10y agoGoogle's specific interview standards only select for academic rigor, not just successful software skills. Look at how many failed or poorly designed products and libs Google has released.
- Apocryphon 10y agoI've always said there seems to be a weird relationship in tech between "the industry" and academia. On one hand, there's a growing disconnect between the everyday API gluing-frameworks galore-trudging through someone's code instead of rolling your own nature of day to day work vs. the clean algorithms of school. On the other, there's a youthful, even immature, vibe of all-nighters and casualness for the sake of casualness and Silicon Valley perks. Maybe this is what happens when an industry is built around worshipping whiz kids. If CS in SV was about venerating NASA/aerospace code, less flashy but very very stable, well-engineered stuff that lives are dependent upon, it'd look a lot more like EE and other more traditional engineering fields.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoMade a similar comment above, but that was entirely true for myself. I have worked on amazing things as we all have in life, petabyte databases, and just the most incredible setups. But when it comes to an interview, I cannot get a job several levels below my own (without referrals). With referrals, I am offered the moon and the stars, complete pick out of a tremendous number of amazing jobs. But any random interview, and I totally bomb it. I wonder how many out there are like that as well. It feels rather strange from my perspective, but maybe it's fairly normal?
- maverick_iceman 10y agoYou cannot get a job at a top company without referral/recruiter looking you up. Any such company is totally swamped by the number of resumes submitted and the chance of getting an interview is practically zero.
- whenwillitstop 10y agoThis is not even close to being true. People get hired into top companies all the time.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]