4 ms·
"As a surgeon I appreciate planning the operation before cutting the person open." Your comment seems trivially true to me. How can one possibly begin the seco
by Waterluvian 10y ago
"As a surgeon I appreciate planning the operation before cutting the person open."
Your comment seems trivially true to me. How can one possibly begin the second without the first? And yet people try it all the time!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- raldi 10y agoIt's not a great analogy, because surgery is not a inherently creative process the way game development is. Plenty of games are created by jumping right in and starting to code, and then seeing where that takes you. For example, the throwaway game that inspired Portal. Of course, eventually you do have to take periodic breaks to review things and plan the next phase.
- lostgame 10y agoIf this was the case we also wouldn't have these things called 'test units' which ensure the code does, uh, what it was planned to do. ;)
- duiker101 10y agoPlenty great games came from exploring a a game mechanic more than from a level design. There are really a lot of games where the look of something can really mean nothing at all. In today's industry an overlook like this might be useful in level design but I can't really see it having a big impact on the actual development of the gameplay as long as you know what actions the player can perform you don't need to know where they are going to be placed or what they will look like.
- brenschluss 10y agoIn Zelda's case, the level design _is_ the game mechanic - where you have to go to get a key, how the game forces you to double back in a dungeon, falling from one floor to the other through a hole, etc.
- duiker101 10y agoI disagree, all the things you listed are game mechanics, but they have nothing to do with level design. as a developer I should have all this different mechanics working independently of where they are in the level.
- brenschluss 10y agoYou speak as if "how the level design" comes after "what mechanic the game needs". I think it's simultaneous. For example: If I say "Oh, it would be really interesting if there's a Dungeon of Reflection in which the entire dungeon is symmetrical, and the monsters always copy the character's movement", then that would require some careful level design, which having worked out, could translate into a mechanic. Operating in reverse is much more difficult and ends up stuffing mechanics into a sense of play. "It's easy in code to make the character teleport! Now.. what should we do with this?"
- hulahoof 10y ago"A day of coding saves an hour of planning" is one of the first mantras to stick with me (I find it holds true for me) Edit: I was also hoping there would be an album or collection of the Zelda assets - is it just the embedded ones on the page they released?
- mustacheemperor 10y agoAs an agile surgeon, I focus on immediate deliverables - we can figure out how to restart the heart once we've iterated breaking the ribcage a few times.
- __s 10y ago& the patient pays for that kind of service! He has a meeting to get to this afternoon
- phjesusthatguy3 10y agoon the one hand, I refuse to believe this is true. on the other hand, I've been subject to one surgery and been third-party to multiple others, and can't see how this isn't true.
- saganus 10y agoThat's... scary.
- rokosbasilisk 10y agopretty sure you just described exploratory surgery.
- jowiar 10y agoGo to a good art museum and see the "studies" associated with many pieces of art. Before the final product, the artist has a bunch of experiments with techniques, framing, and the like. One of the things we often lack in software is a good medium for exploring mechanics. Getting something to the point where we can conduct an "Is this fun?" test or more generically "Does this serve the purpose" without a massive development undertaking.
- vvanders 10y agoYup, there's a very common game design technique called "White Boxing" where you design your levels out in white boxes until they're fun and then art comes in afterwards and makes it look realistic.
- richardboegli 10y ago> One of the things we often lack in software is a good medium for exploring mechanics. > Getting something to the point where we can conduct an "Is this fun?" test or more generically "Does this serve the purpose" A medium? Would you care to expand on this point? While I agree that more work could be done on speeding up the tools used, the process / concept / activity itself already exists, so I am not sure what you mean by medium. PROTOTYPING is a fundamental part of the software engineering process (and other engineering disciplines), but I see it get missed A LOT in software development, for a variety of reasons. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_prototyping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_prototyping As vvanders has already said, "White Boxing" is a common technique for video game development.