5 ms·
Interesting and surprising, especially the experience thing. I think I am a significantly better engineer than earlier in my career, so I assumed experience wou
by collyw 10y ago
Interesting and surprising, especially the experience thing. I think I am a significantly better engineer than earlier in my career, so I assumed experience would count for a fair bit. Then again I have inherited projects from experienced guys who make crap high level architecture decisions and the code is way more difficult to work with than it ought to be.
But then this article seems to be measuring interview performance, not actual ability on the job. So is any of it actually relevant at all?
- leeny 10y agoHey, author here. You're absolutely right. We hope that with time and data, the interview process can get better at predicting on-the-job performance -- one of the things we're really interested in is seeing how predictive different interview questions can be. To do that, we're also working on collecting data around what happens after interviewing.io users find jobs.
- techman9 10y agoWhat are some metrics that you expect to use to measure on-the-job performance?
- hibikir 10y agoMost of the things that make us better during our career have nothing to do with programming faster: If anything, they can make us program slower, and do worse in interviews. For instance, an interview I took last year came with a premise that I found downright bonkers. It was based on code the company had in production, but it stopped being a good problem to look at years before. I was having trouble coming up with the right tradeoffs for the implementation because all my experience was telling me that the entire approach was misguided in the first place, so the problem should not be solved. I passed, but it was a far rougher performance than I would have liked. There's also how being far from college makes the least important knowledge gained fade away, and the least important thing I studied was memorizing algorithms. I write new algorithms at work sometimes, and I implement off the shelf ones too, but I don't have to recall them off the top of my head. Nobody has to implement distributed consensus algorithms under time pressure, or write HyperLogLog from memory. So ultimately, there's what easy to measure, and then there's what is valuable and important. We go with what is easy, and those are things that are taught in college. Understanding the right level of testing or designing a system for observability are far more valuable in the long run: It's crazy how much downtime in well known companies comes from people not learning those things in college. But since we are bad at measuring those things, and kids right out of school don't know them, we don't interview for that. And sadly this is why we all end up hiring by network so much: We can't tell if someone is good in a day, and we can't really ask people to dedicate two weeks to work with us in a probationary period if they have real jobs, but we sure can recall quality former coworkers and ask them to join in.
- nickbauman 10y agoMost pedagogy, over time, gravitates toward what's easy to measure, not what's valuable to learn. So we've been very lucky in hiring by network even though we kinda feel terrible about it. On the other hand we're hiring more women now too as a result, not least because women are now much more conscientious about managing their network of other female developers than men.
- aquadrop 10y agoI guess it might be because with experience your expectations also rise. You may be easily qualified for starting programming position somewhere, but now, when you're more experienced, you'll aim higher, right?
- davedx 10y agoI am conducting interviews at the moment. I would say experience gives you a much better chance of getting to interview but once you are there other factors can be more important, like motivation and communication abilities.
- grigjd3 10y agoIf someone works at a firm with bad processes / poor or no code review, this can actually make their experience a detriment as they continue to use and reinforce bad habits.