3 ms·
These are good comments. >A righteous operating system should be a programming language. Like the Commodore 64, VIC 20, TRS 80 and many early home computers.
by Clubber 10y ago
These are good comments.
>A righteous operating system should be a programming language.
Like the Commodore 64, VIC 20, TRS 80 and many early home computers.
>Any decent software environment ought to have a fully featured database, built in, and no need for a 'filesystem'.
Microsoft tried to have MSSQL as a file system in Windows called WinFS.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WinFS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WinFS
If he's referring to non-relational, then most FS as we know it are key/value databases. You put in a key: c:\files\myfile.txt (/usr/root/myfile) and you get a byte array. It's more sophisticated than simple numeric tokens because it adds a 3d structure in the key.
Part of the reason for these seemingly odd things is we stand on the shoulders of giants that came before us. Because of this, iterative technologies must be backwards compatible to survive.
- gavanwoolery 10y agoWith regards to standing on the shoulders of giants, the rational part of me wholeheartedly agrees, but the kid in me just wants to burn it all to the ground and rebuild it from scratch. :) Of course, it is nearly impossible to rewrite things better because inevitably you hit one of these traps: not enough time/money, the bureaucracy that is attached to money, the "too many chefs" problem, or the inadequate supply of experienced/battle-hardened minds to put on such a project - i.e. people that have written compilers, operating systems, GUIs, etc - enough times over to know what they are doing.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoWhereas the strategy worked for AS/400's. Helped them be more consistent, reliable, and easily managed. I'm more for pluggable storage with filesystems, object systems, and RDBMS's being options to choose from. Microsoft's failure doesn't invalidate the concept, though, so much as their use-case and solution didn't work out.
- tlb 10y agoA database as a file system is fundamentally a good idea. But so much software expects a regular file system, and it's surprisingly hard to implement an efficient regular file system on top of a relational DB.