3 ms·
I don't have anything to add to the blog post itself, but I find the complaints about the writing style pretty strange, especially to HN. I never even try to re
by golergka 10y ago
I don't have anything to add to the blog post itself, but I find the complaints about the writing style pretty strange, especially to HN. I never even try to read New Yorker articles anymore, which get shared and upvoted here so abundantly: lazy, wordy writing that concentrates on people instead of concepts, tries to reason about important things through emotions instead of logic and in general tries to be prose instead of journalism is insufferable to me.
After that, Taleb's writing is like fresh air: straight and to the point, logical and precise. He's using concepts that I myself utilize in analysis of outside world, shows great intellectual honesty and backs his claims with a plethora of sources. If anything, I expected HN to be full of fans of this writing style, not New Yorker's.
- sosodaft 10y agoSeconded. I found his style genuinely delightful. People are more likely to comment about things that piss them off though, right?
- j2kun 10y agoThis is anything but straight. New Yorker is also not straight, but hackers are not the intended audience of New Yorker articles. Normal people prefer stories about people to conceptual discussions. FWIW I think there's some good reason for this. Discussions purely about high minded concepts over the lives and experiences of individuals tend to wind their way inexorably toward stupidity or irrelevance. When you're discussing policy making, all that really matters is how it affects people. That's not to say you can't use anecdote to mislead, but that's a different class of sin.