14 ms·
More importantly, the headline should read: "Police use high time resolution data from modern water meter against man charged with murder." Basically this Abst
by superkuh 10y ago
More importantly, the headline should read: "Police use high time resolution data from modern water meter against man charged with murder."
Basically this Abstruse Goose comic, http://abstrusegoose.com/553 http://abstrusegoose.com/553 , about the dangers of utility data logging have come true. The greater the time resolution of such things the more can be inferred. Such high resolution is completely uneeded and complex in order to just charge for usage. The new wireless meters could simply send daily lump sums and still be wireless and easy. But instead they abuse the functionality in order to intrude on the lives of everyone.
- Hondor 10y agoIsn't it a good thing to record data that helps solve a murder? The police are still getting it with a warrant and presumably from physical access to the device, so it's not the same worry as bulk monitoring.
- Filligree 10y agoIn the case of a murder, it's a good thing. The risk is always the chance of abuse, and although in the case of water stats it's hard to imagine how you'd abuse it, having more information always means a higher chance. Ideally we'd want to get the benefits without the abuse, but that requires a solid bureaucracy and strong rules.
- WalterBright 10y agoYou can tell when someone's home or not from utility usage.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Godel_unicode 10y agoTimers and automation are a thing.
- Symbiote 10y agoThose patterns would be easily detected in the dataset. I tried logging my electricity use. You can easily see what time I wake up each day, when I get home, whether I watch TV or not, whether I cook using the microwave or the hob. It doesn't show up on my graph, but I'd bet from the data you can see exactly when I go to bed, since I plug in my phone (+1W) and switch off the last light (-5W). Within all this, the fridge compressor turning on and off is easily ignored.
- ansgri 10y agoThus you have a training dataset. Train a statistical model, and with enough programmability in your smart home it will be easy to forge a rather normal-looking pattern in your absence. And I'd probably use some special fire-proofed energy dissipation device instead of the more powerful real ones (e.g. the hob). EDIT: the internet surfing patterns are another story. But you can probably VPN to your home through some newly-installed network interface and access the net as if you were there.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoExactly so. And then there's the corollary of times you come home, walk around back and drink beer on the patio watching the sunset with friends and eating takeout.
- WalterBright 10y agoYes, by the exact amount of current used, the logger can tell what you've got on at any moment. It can be correlated with water usage as well. It'll log how many times you flush, and whether you brush your teeth. I wouldn't be terribly surprised if the government tries to require a device that logs all our conversations at home. It'll be sold as "crucial for law enforcement". The Echo is a technological marvel. But who's to say Amazon doesn't get a "national security letter" one day where they're forced to send a patch to the machine to have it log everything? Some day, if I'm bedridden or some such, I'd welcome an Echo in the house. Until then, I'd rather get up and turn a manual switch. I could use the exercise anyway :-)
- supergeek133 10y agoYou've always been able to make this guess from lights on/off, windows, etc. It might have become easier to some people.
- Quarrelsome 10y agoits a fine line. There is a great fear of false positives from such inference. Let us imagine for a second that there is a legitimate reason for that water use that he doesn't wish to disclose because it would incriminate him for something else? Hypothetically speaking if you were doing some grey-hat, "illegal" probing/hack at the time of a murder the police question you about; admitting to your actual activity could result in more time behind bars than a murder. If this activity was somehow vaguely recorded and correlated with an activity of the murderer then you have a serious problem.
- fixermark 10y ago"A legitimate reason for that water use that he doesn't wish to disclose because it would incriminate him for something else" is an odd definition of "legitimate." ;)
- lotsofpulp 10y agoJust because something is legally a crime doesn't mean it's not legitimate.
- panzagl 10y agoActually, that's exactly what it means.
- pdkl95 10y agoNo, it doesn't. Legitimacy (or ethics) is not derived from law (or the reverse). It's possible to be guilty of a crime (by the law) for legitimate reasons. These extenuating circumstances are improper generalizations or other imperfections in the law.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Sir_Substance 10y ago>Isn't it a good thing to record data that helps solve a murder? Recording everyones data everywhere just in case it might be relevant to an extremely rare event like a murder is very dangerous. The use of NSA recording capabilities by employees to digitally stalk victims of their affection (LOVEINT) is a clear example of how badly this kind of collection can go wrong.
- dmd 10y agoYour first statement is correct, but not because of what you said in your second. Google "ubiquitous law enforcement" for some good reading.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThat was an excellent read, as Vernor Vinge usually is. I've certainly used anti-surveillance arguments like "what if some employee misuses the data", and I mean them, but it's not my fundamental objection. On a much deeper level, I worry about surveillance as an inherent harm. Partly as the death of privacy (a right in itself, to me), largely as a de facto power transfer to the state. I think Seeing Like a State is right when it argues that states depend on 'legibility'. If it can't be logged, measured, or predicted, it can't be handled on the statistical level where states have to operate. And so everything that increases the legibility of our lives eases the real power of the state, without any need to expand its legal power.
- pdkl95 10y ago> Seeing Like a State is right when it argues that states depend on 'legibility'. http://opentranscripts.org/transcript/no-neutral-ground-burning-world/ http://opentranscripts.org/transcript/no-neutral-ground-burn...
- supergeek133 10y agoSo how much do we hold back technology and the use of it to protect against people committing crimes with it (as mentioned above) This data when used properly (which is probably the case 90%+ of the time) helps to make the world better, or provides efficiency for the company who uses the tools.
- scarygliders 10y agoThere has to be a line drawn somewhere, lest we end up with putting GPS trackers and video recording devices on each and every person. That's obviously a slippery-slope argument, but it's not outwith the realms of possibility that if I can think of doing something like that, politicians (especially those!) can think of it as well.
- kombucha2 10y ago> lest we end up with putting GPS trackers and video recording devices on each and every person. ....phones?
- jasonkostempski 10y agoThat's at least voluntary. For now...
- fixermark 10y agoAs long as it's voluntary, it's fine. We should keep educating people about the risks as long as we don't curtail what people can do with the technology voluntarily.
- jononor 10y ago"Voluntary" is easy to say, but the environment heavily suggests certain choices. A (mobile) phone is these days used or needed for authentication: banking, email, real time communication and social media. Having to forgo those things is not without drawbacks.
- imagist 10y ago1. It doesn't come from physical access to the device: the device is accessed wirelessly. 2. The water company collects all this data from everyone with the device. 3. As the Mirai botnet showed, it's not just the government who might have access to that data.
- kanzure 10y ago> Isn't it a good thing to record data that helps solve a murder? You might trust the current custodians of $BACKDOOR, but do you trust all future possible custodians that have dominion over that role? Keep in mind that nothing is technically restricting them to look only at possible murder.
- stephenboyd 10y agoThe Amazon Echo records data from all of its users, not just the murderers. It's creeping close to bulk monitoring.
- throwawayy24 10y agoIt is bulk monitoring. My four kids each have a google tablet. My autistic daughter has learned a lot through "OK, Google", which means everything said in my household for the past six years is sitting on Google's servers, waiting for America's Stasi to commandeer it. Frankly, it's bullshit that Google didn't know what was going on, or that I didn't either.
- autokad 10y agothats why i didnt want them to install the 'smart' meters for electricity. i told them I didnt want it, but they said they would shut off my electricity unless i complied.
- fixermark 10y agoYou didn't want them installed because you were concerned they might rat you out when you murdered someone? ;)
- jpitz 10y agoI wonder what the market is for a utility usage randomizer that fuzzes this data?
- w8rbt 10y agoWhile it is likely illegal at various levels, there are probably ways to interfere with the smart meter via RF.
- jenamety 10y agoI believe building your own 'storage' units would be better (letting you draw from these as you need, without monitoring) thus having a continuously slow supply of water,gas, electricity coming from the grid. As long as these storage units don't simply begin to 'top off' when they are drained, the usage could be masked by averaging and predicting demand. very simplified water day 6am - Toilet flush & hand wash 2 Gal 7am - Shower 36 Gal 8am - Breakfast - Coffee, Oatmeal, Dishwashing - 2 Gal 6pm - Dinner & dishwasher - 8 gal 10pm - flush and brush - 2.5 Gal So you'd want a constant 2.1 gallons to be fed in from the street per hour, and you'd need a minimum 40 gallon reserve tank to cover that day.
- jpitz 10y agoQuite true, but the opportunity for time-of-day rate arbitrage is tempting.
- jgrahamc 10y agoWhen I was a student this murder happened https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Rachel_McLean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Rachel_McLean One important piece of evidence was the record of the number of bus tickets sold at the time/place Tanner said he got the bus (there was also a witness that said he was alone). A single ticket was sold, not two he had claimed. That was 1991.
- supergeek133 10y agoWe either assume the data will more often than not be used for negative reasons, and stop it, or we assume it will be used mostly for positive reasons and allow it to improve the world. If we do the latter, we treat the minority cases as a crime. Just as we do when police use their access to stalk people. That being said, I DO think we have poor transparency in these cases of who has access to what. I've always said that if it were publicly available to see how many times someone has run my license place and/or drivers license I would be really upset.
- mc32 10y agoI think it would be important to know if Amazon can or would release information/data which could be used to exonerate someone suspected of a crime.