2 ms·
For my city in particular, I would say the solution is more parking, but further from the city at public transport hubs, and remove the parking in the CBD. Whic
by ehnto 10y ago
For my city in particular, I would say the solution is more parking, but further from the city at public transport hubs, and remove the parking in the CBD. Which will give way to a more walkable CBD. Our CBD is small enough to walk around and it's inner public transport is free and frequent if you're not personally mobile enough for walking far.
It wouldn't be feasible to build out train infrastructure to reach all of suburbia but we definitely have some decent existing train lines.
My perfect commute from suburbia would be driving to a carpark beside a seperated bike path, then riding my bike the last mile and through a carless CBD. Where others might do the same but take a train instead of biking.
An argument against is car parking for less mobile people nearer their destination, but for where I live there are never free parks on the streets anyway, and you need to park in a multi-story. So perhaps a compromise and have the multi-story carparks on the fringe of the CBD, then better last-mile public transit for getting closer to your destination would work.
I think like many issues, people are often polarized to an extreme of no cars or only cars, but the best case likely sits somewhere inbetween.
- wcummings 10y agoPark-and-ride is totally a thing. People in the burbs should (and in some places, do) drive to rail stations outside the city and park in lots there. This is not "last mile", though, ideally you drive a relatively short distance to a rail station. Most of the trip should be via train. This reduces congestion in the city and accommodates suburban-types.
- m_mueller 10y agoAre you living in Denver? I visited there once and it seemed to me the way you describe. In any case one of the better American cities I've seen so far. I absolutely agree that all important needs should be addressed - what works in Europe isn't necessarily the best solution for the US. That being said I do think there's a lack of good public infrastructure in general and this is IMO a shame - in many places around the world, public infrastructure is something people are proud of and something that makes many lives incrementally a bit better. Replacing 1-2h of daily commute full of car jams, bad air and stressed out drivers with standing or even sitting in a clean train while reading Hacker News appears to be a really low hanging fruit to me. For the first and last mile I think that shared autonomous cars/small buses will be a very good and cost effective solution - think of it like the limousine / shuttle services at airports.