4 ms·
>Have parking spaces outside the center and then automatic electric shuttle trains to transport people in. I agree, and in fact I do this (park at BART in the
by closeparen 10y ago
>Have parking spaces outside the center and then automatic electric shuttle trains to transport people in.
I agree, and in fact I do this (park at BART in the East Bay and ride it into SF). The problem is, no one is advocating constructing these systems where they don't exist. They are advocating a direct ban (or prohibitively high tolls and parking scarcity) to prevent people who live outside the city from entering it at all. With maybe some handwaving about bicycles, or an assertion that walking 4 hours a day is good for you. Some of the same people are even advocating that we eliminate the existing parking at suburban light rail stations!
Because clearly what we need is even more pressure for even more people to pay astronomical rents.
- NotOscarWilde 10y ago> The problem is, no one is advocating this. My city's (Prague's) administration actually supports this a lot, but since the city districts (and not the administration) actually hold power over what gets built in a specific district, and no district wants a big parking lot, the situation remains as bad as ever. Or worse, bad compromises get through -- for instance park at the very edge of the city and then walk 10 minutes to a bus which takes another 15 minutes before you reach any subway station. A great political move to destroy the whole idea.
- ehnto 10y agoThe issue with things like raising pricing on existing parking infrastructure is that it doesn't fix the issue, it just pushes it down the line. In otherwords, I still park in the city but I also get paid more to compensate for the costs of commuting, because it is still the best option available to me. If they shifted the parking to the fringe of the CBD at various transport hubs and removed it entirely from the CBD then there would be more usable space for city inhabitants, uninhibited public transport and separated foot/bike traffic. All much better options than a car doing nothing on prime real estate for 8 hours a day.
- closeparen 10y agoI agree high quality park-n-ride from the edges is the way to do it. It's also hard to overstate the efficiency of parking smaller personal motor vehicles like ebikes, motorcycles, and scooters, which can do car-level distances comfortably (modulo freight and ice). But given the income required to live in the city vs. in the surrounding area, I'm skeptical that we should be creating more playground for the well-heeled inhabitants of trendy neighborhoods at the expense of people who need to live car-sized distances away from the CBD (and transit hubs) to have decent homes at their income levels. Maybe if we thought the resultant construction could house at least as many new residents as the drivers it displaced.