71 ms·
>They're going to see those Other People over there paying them to shut up, sit down, and be useless. Right. And what I'm getting at is removing those Other P
by Gargoyle 10y ago
>They're going to see those Other People over there paying them to shut up, sit down, and be useless.
Right. And what I'm getting at is removing those Other People from the equation. I see that as a completely essential part of the process, and one not many people have come around to yet.
We can't have overlords of any sort for this to work out well. Not a government handing out checks. Not a few companies in Silicon Valley handing out checks. Ownership (if the concept even survives) of the sources of production and wealth generation must be shared equally by all.
For it to work out well, at least.
We can easily not go down that radical path, of course. Continue with small modifications to the systems we have. No doubt that's what we'll try at first. But as you're pointing out, that's not going to be a satisfactory solution. I agree with you on that point.
So I think it's worth looking at what the ideal would look like and then try to find the least painful path in that direction.
UBI as currently envisioned is a half-measure. A stopgap at best.
- Kalium 10y agoYou know, it occurs to me that this radical idea you describe has a name. It seems like maybe people have tried to get their previously with revolutions.
- Gargoyle 10y agoWhile it resembles some concepts of the past, it doesn't resemble any actual implementations of those concepts, so I intentionally avoid attaching those labels to it. They do not accurately describe what eventually needs to happen.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Kalium 10y agoI will say only this: you may wish to think long and hard on how all previous attempted implementations went in the same undesirable direction. It's perhaps possible that this is somewhat less than entirely coincidental.
- Gargoyle 10y agoThink about what I've actually suggested here and not the comparisons you're leaping to. As I said, I didn't avoid those comparisons by accident. What I'm suggesting is not the same thing.