4 ms·
So if what people want are car-based cities that work well, what should a city planner do? Take measures to limit growth? Massive taxes on new construction? Th
by criddell 10y ago
So if what people want are car-based cities that work well, what should a city planner do? Take measures to limit growth? Massive taxes on new construction?
The city I grew up in had a population of around 27,000 people 30 years ago. I think it's roughly the same today. Unsurprisingly, traffic and parking work about as well today is it did when I was a teenager.
- nickff 10y agoThe Greater Vancouver Regional District is made up of many municipalities, so if only one limits growth, the others will probably absorb that additional population (causing increases in congestion). Additional taxes on new construction would exacerbate any traffic problems by pushing people out to the suburbs (, especially with Vancouver's already high housing prices). I would argue for precisely the opposite: allow for much greater construction everywhere, with fewer restrictions. City planners' efforts to 'sculpt' a city usually involves restricting supply to force people to live where the planners want them to, which drives up prices and drives population to suburbs.
- criddell 10y agoLuckily for me, the suburbs are exactly where I want to be.
- criddell 10y agoYou're thinking about housing construction and I was thinking more about commercial. If you limit business growth or make it very costly for new businesses to enter the area, then you will probably cut off massive population growth as well.
- alkonaut 10y agoThe cost of living goes up with popularity. Rents make sure you pay for the privilege of living in a popular place. Car infrastructure like roads and parking doesn't scale so the only real alternative to congestion is rent - I.e congestion fees and more expensive parking. If it was (say) $100 a day to enter a major city by car, and as much again to park, then congestion would be over. You might argue this is surrendering the roads to the 1% which it is, but it also quickly funds new infrastructure and public transport.