3 ms·
> But the number of jobs in Manhattan didn't go down to n - (# of book binders) because in a macro sense what used to be spent on book binding is being spent on
by kbenson 10y ago
> But the number of jobs in Manhattan didn't go down to n - (# of book binders) because in a macro sense what used to be spent on book binding is being spent on something else. Maybe it created a thousand jobs at print shops (for example).
But the assumption here is that there are still lots of jobs that need people to shift people into. As a resource, we're consistently reducing the areas in which it's appropriate and cost effective to use people instead of some other resource.
This happens. Resources that were previously used for many things are displaced by other resources which are fundamentally better in those categories. Think stone age. Eventually stone as a resource was completely surpassed in almost every area it was previously useful in. It's value has been reduced to the point that if you have a large quantity of unsorted stone material, it probably costs more to sort the useful bits than you can make selling them, and without a local market that wants to use it, you're stuck trying to figure out the least costly way to either store or dispose of it.
I hope we aren't transforming ourselves into the equivalent of stone, where we end up that figuring out which select few of us is capable of contributing in some way is more costly than producing a product slightly worse quality but much cheaper using automation the majority of the time, for the majority of fields.
Hopefully I'm dead wrong and we transition to something far more uplifting, because it's depressing to think this way.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI don't think you have to assume that at the time of the shift there are lots of jobs to shift into, only that as it shifts the economy will create new jobs. Further I think those shifts are on the order of years not days, as things shift over its going to be useful to cross train. For example, right now there is a possibility that trucks can become self driving so if you drive a truck you need to think of three things; 1) How much longer might this be a viable way to earn a living, 2) what sort of new jobs are currently being advertised as unfilled, 3) what resources can I apply to cross train into something different than truck driving.