4 ms·
I don't disagree with what you've stated, but I think the disconnect with what you've stated and what the GP stated is that a specific unit of money doesn't buy
by kbenson 10y ago
I don't disagree with what you've stated, but I think the disconnect with what you've stated and what the GP stated is that a specific unit of money doesn't buy/pay for the same amout of jobs when applied in different areas (whether "area" be geographic or sector). For example, taking money that previously was applied to 1000 coal miners and applying it towards a software company yields far fewer software engineers.
Additionally, people are a resource, but a very finicky one. You would expect them to move to where there is a need for them, and to do what it takes to make themselves usable, but there are many external factors that make that far less likely than it could be, such as family, property, and various features of human nature. So, as money flows from labor-intensive industries to non-labor intensive industries, or transforms a previously high-labor industry into a low-labor one, what happens to labor as it increasingly loses value? What happens when the value of labor falls below the threshold required for human survival for increasingly more segments of the economy?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoFair enough, but this "what the GP stated is that a specific unit of money doesn't buy/pay for the same amout of jobs when applied in different areas" is the basic fallacy. It is misses the point. At a microeconomic scale, people are displaced. We saw last week an article on one of the few book binders left in Manhattan, there used to be hundreds of book binders. They stopped binding books. But the number of jobs in Manhattan didn't go down to n - (# of book binders) because in a macro sense what used to be spent on book binding is being spent on something else. Maybe it created a thousand jobs at print shops (for example). We completely agree that people aren't fungible. Just like cattle die in a drought, people without marketable skills go hungry and homeless. I, and many folks I have talked to agree that one of the reasons you tax business is to fund transition plans for people being left behind by changes in the job market. Whether that is retraining programs, temporary shelters, or tuition assistance for additional education. In my mind I consider that social justice matter to be independent of the macroeconomic mechanism of job creation.
- csallen 10y ago...because in a macro sense what used to be spent on book binding is being spent on something else. Maybe it created a thousand jobs at print shops (for example). This assumes that there will always be a "something else". Something else for people to work at, something else for banks to invest in. My question is, what guarantees the appearance of this "something else"? Looking at past examples, these new jobs seem to come from advancements in technology that both improved human lives (and thus were in high demand) and also required human labor to operate (and thus provided jobs). For example, we no longer need nearly as many farmers, but these people have all been freed up to pilot commercial airplanes, program computers, repair cars, operate print shops, etc. But what if these trends don't hold up? What if the value-producing technological advancements of the future continue to eliminate jobs, but require radically less human labor to operate? My best guess is that people will be pushed into less technology-driven and more service-driven pursuits. Instead of print technologies eliminating book binders but providing print shop jobs, we will be eliminating print shop jobs and getting — I don't know — more masseuses, therapists, cleaners, gardeners, personal chefs, etc? Basically the service economy we see emerging now — people performing what were previously considered "luxury tasks" for other people. I suppose I've talked myself out of some of my former skepticism. We don't need new jobs, because we have plenty of "old" ways to provide value that become more broadly affordable as workers are freed up to do them. However, if this leads to a society in which the masses perform menial tasks for the rich who fill a limited number of high leverage technological positions, that could cause tremendous cultural problems.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoActually I was trying to point out a causal relationship between capital (in this case money) in an economy causing new jobs to appear. There isn't an assumption there. You can flip that around, if there wasn't "something else" to spend money on there would be no reason to have it.
- kbenson 10y ago> But the number of jobs in Manhattan didn't go down to n - (# of book binders) because in a macro sense what used to be spent on book binding is being spent on something else. Maybe it created a thousand jobs at print shops (for example). But the assumption here is that there are still lots of jobs that need people to shift people into. As a resource, we're consistently reducing the areas in which it's appropriate and cost effective to use people instead of some other resource. This happens. Resources that were previously used for many things are displaced by other resources which are fundamentally better in those categories. Think stone age. Eventually stone as a resource was completely surpassed in almost every area it was previously useful in. It's value has been reduced to the point that if you have a large quantity of unsorted stone material, it probably costs more to sort the useful bits than you can make selling them, and without a local market that wants to use it, you're stuck trying to figure out the least costly way to either store or dispose of it. I hope we aren't transforming ourselves into the equivalent of stone, where we end up that figuring out which select few of us is capable of contributing in some way is more costly than producing a product slightly worse quality but much cheaper using automation the majority of the time, for the majority of fields. Hopefully I'm dead wrong and we transition to something far more uplifting, because it's depressing to think this way.