6 ms·
I'm a bit skeptical that "we'll always find a way to quickly replace jobs" will stand the test of time, especially when the primary evidence given is, "We
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I'm a bit skeptical that "we'll always find a way to
quickly replace jobs" will stand the test of time,
especially when the primary evidence given is, "Well
that's how it's worked out so far."
Perhaps your skepticism can be allayed by looking at the mechanism. Money, in the form of capital, flows through an economy from providers to consumers. With a functional banking system capital doesn't accumulate. Even when a company like Apple has $200B in "the bank", that money is being lent out to others to build things and start businesses etc. Building stuff consumes labor and that transfers money back to the labor force which then uses it to purchase goods and services. All basic economics but the key is that the existence of money (capital) creates an economic force. Banks cannot simply sit on a pile of dollar bills and pay out 1.2% interest on that, they would go broke. They need to make a return on it so they find people (economic force) who will use the money to create additional value.
In many ways its like "running out of water" which on its face is preposterous. The planet is literally covered in the stuff. The mechanism (evaporation and condensation) which move it around the planet can put too much or too little somewhere but we'll never be permanently "out" of water. It will rain somewhere at some point (or snow) because water is evaporating from the oceans every day.
Economies are very much like that as well, they may have capital dry up in one area (like Appalachia) but it is probably raining somewhere else (like San Francisco). But the mechanism of buying and selling products or services is a constant force to move the money around.
So that money will always find a way to be spent. And that means jobs. They may be different than the ones before but they will get created.
- kbenson 10y agoI don't disagree with what you've stated, but I think the disconnect with what you've stated and what the GP stated is that a specific unit of money doesn't buy/pay for the same amout of jobs when applied in different areas (whether "area" be geographic or sector). For example, taking money that previously was applied to 1000 coal miners and applying it towards a software company yields far fewer software engineers. Additionally, people are a resource, but a very finicky one. You would expect them to move to where there is a need for them, and to do what it takes to make themselves usable, but there are many external factors that make that far less likely than it could be, such as family, property, and various features of human nature. So, as money flows from labor-intensive industries to non-labor intensive industries, or transforms a previously high-labor industry into a low-labor one, what happens to labor as it increasingly loses value? What happens when the value of labor falls below the threshold required for human survival for increasingly more segments of the economy?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoFair enough, but this "what the GP stated is that a specific unit of money doesn't buy/pay for the same amout of jobs when applied in different areas" is the basic fallacy. It is misses the point. At a microeconomic scale, people are displaced. We saw last week an article on one of the few book binders left in Manhattan, there used to be hundreds of book binders. They stopped binding books. But the number of jobs in Manhattan didn't go down to n - (# of book binders) because in a macro sense what used to be spent on book binding is being spent on something else. Maybe it created a thousand jobs at print shops (for example). We completely agree that people aren't fungible. Just like cattle die in a drought, people without marketable skills go hungry and homeless. I, and many folks I have talked to agree that one of the reasons you tax business is to fund transition plans for people being left behind by changes in the job market. Whether that is retraining programs, temporary shelters, or tuition assistance for additional education. In my mind I consider that social justice matter to be independent of the macroeconomic mechanism of job creation.
- csallen 10y ago...because in a macro sense what used to be spent on book binding is being spent on something else. Maybe it created a thousand jobs at print shops (for example). This assumes that there will always be a "something else". Something else for people to work at, something else for banks to invest in. My question is, what guarantees the appearance of this "something else"? Looking at past examples, these new jobs seem to come from advancements in technology that both improved human lives (and thus were in high demand) and also required human labor to operate (and thus provided jobs). For example, we no longer need nearly as many farmers, but these people have all been freed up to pilot commercial airplanes, program computers, repair cars, operate print shops, etc. But what if these trends don't hold up? What if the value-producing technological advancements of the future continue to eliminate jobs, but require radically less human labor to operate? My best guess is that people will be pushed into less technology-driven and more service-driven pursuits. Instead of print technologies eliminating book binders but providing print shop jobs, we will be eliminating print shop jobs and getting — I don't know — more masseuses, therapists, cleaners, gardeners, personal chefs, etc? Basically the service economy we see emerging now — people performing what were previously considered "luxury tasks" for other people. I suppose I've talked myself out of some of my former skepticism. We don't need new jobs, because we have plenty of "old" ways to provide value that become more broadly affordable as workers are freed up to do them. However, if this leads to a society in which the masses perform menial tasks for the rich who fill a limited number of high leverage technological positions, that could cause tremendous cultural problems.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>In many ways its like "running out of water" which on its face is preposterous. The planet is literally covered in the stuff. The vast majority of that water is not drinkable. THAT is the main issue. Obviously we won't ever run out of the H2O molecule, but there is a good chance that the availability of cheap, potable water will be a major issue in the coming decades.
- ChuckMcM 10y ago... but there is a good chance that the availability of cheap, potable water will be a major issue in the coming decades. Actually there isn't. It is possible that for a given population of people in a particular place on the planet they may find there is a shortage of water, but as long as the sun shines it will continue to evaporate trillions of tons of water which will then move over land and condense out of the atmosphere. Its also possible to get water out of the air where it didn't previously condense on its own.[1][2] [1] http://www.islandsky.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=117&Itemid=78 http://www.islandsky.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=a... [2] http://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2011/03/07/the-fog-collectors-harvesting-water-from-thin-air/ http://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2011/03/07/the-fog-collectors-h...
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>It is possible that for a given population of people in a particular place on the planet they may find there is a shortage of water Yes, that's what I meant. And this can be a MAJOR issue. Not sure why you're trying to downplay its importance. I mean you can look at places like Haiti today to understand the true effects of regional clean water shortages. They are absolutely devastating. The other thing you haven't mentioned is contamination, which is a lot more difficult for the natural water cycle to handle. For example, underground water reservoirs are an important source of clean water for many villages, towns and cities all over the world. If they get contaminated, you can't just wait for that water to evaporate and then condense back as relatively clean water.
- ChuckMcM 10y ago
- petra 10y agoYour analysis is correct, money does flow and tries to get used,thus creating jobs. but still, the gdp share that goes towards workers salaries, in 2013, was the lowest since 1929: https://www.dougsguides.com/content/whats https://www.dougsguides.com/content/whats And with the rising income inequality , the same amount of money might highly reward specific professions, leaving others with no salary.