4 ms·
It's true that you have to draw a line somewhere based on technical and business constraints, but an important takeaway of the names article is that you almost
by kibwen 10y ago
It's true that you have to draw a line somewhere based on technical and business constraints, but an important takeaway of the names article is that you almost certainly don't need to do anything with a name other than treat it as an opaque string that can be displayed back to the user. For example, I'm struggling to think of a good reason why user registration would require separate first name and last name fields, and yet this practice is overwhelmingly common. For that matter, why do you want my real name at all, considering that it can't be used as a unique ID anyway?
- Frondo 10y agoThat's easy, it's to make better marketing materials. "Dear [first name]," flows better than "Dear [opaque string],".
- kibwen 10y agoThat's what the marketing department may believe, but in reality that's super creepy. Let's not pretend that I'm on a friendly first-name basis with corporations, or that in reality I'm anything more than an autogenerated numeric ID in a database as far as the corporation is concerned. Furthermore, nobody but my mother calls me by my real first name, and this holds for half of my cohort. And why does any company think that their marketing correspondence is welcome in the first place?
- mysterypie 10y ago> nobody but my mother calls me by my real first name, and this holds for half of my cohort Really? I've been assuming that addressing people by first name--even people you've just met--is now the default, at least for the United States and Canada. Are you in the USA/Canada, by the way? I know that it used to be rude to address someone by their first name unless you knew them well. You had to say, Mr. last-name or Mrs/Ms./Miss last-name. I know this from old movies. But I thought that the etiquette has changed completely: First name is fine and last name sounds rather formal. Do others have a different experience?
- kibwen 10y agoFor whatever reason, a large number of the people I know go by names that are not their legal first name. Some go by their middle; some drop letters from their first name in idiosyncratic ways; some keep the same pronunciation but have a different spelling; some change the spelling while leaving the pronunciation and then drop letters; some go by irc nicks even in person; a rare few just invent words that have nothing to do with their names and go by that. Maybe it's a unique symptom of growing up in an era where we communicate via online systems that demand unique usernames?
- nercht12 10y agoCould be. If you've heard of someone primarily referred to by their online pseudonym, it may be less awkward calling them that than trying to guess at how they wish to be addressed using their real name. It's still awkward though.
- nercht12 10y agoI personally don't like the shift, even being in the younger crowd. Calling someone by their first name sounds not only presumptuous but leaves you in an awkward spot of guessing whether to use a nickname (you may heard they've been given) or their full first name. With some coworkers, it's fine 'cause we're on a friendly basis anyways, but if I don't know from Adam, I prefer people don't use my first name. It only lowers my respect for them.
- Thrillington 10y agoGive me a genderless honorific and I'm right there with you. Otherwise, a quick correction to ask for use of a nickname seems easier and less embarrassing all around than presuming gender incorrectly.
- tehwalrus 10y agoI really really dont like being called "Joseph" in long form. I know there are some Matthews, Benjamins and a Sybille who agree...
- 10y ago
- Frondo 10y agoI understand what you're saying, but I find the first-name greeting stuff to be probably the least problematic of marketing behaviors big businesses can do. Send me your regular catalog of electronics parts, but it's got my name on it? Sure, whatev, Mouser Electronics. Far creepier is the thing where they use your purchase history to make predictions about your health condition, like where Target would send out baby-related stuff when its algorithms discerned that customers were likely pregnant: http://www.businessinsider.com/the-incredible-story-of-how-target-exposed-a-teen-girls-pregnancy-2012-2 http://www.businessinsider.com/the-incredible-story-of-how-t... Compared to that stuff, "Dear Frondo" seems absolutely benign.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoI've run into a couple of sites that ask for "nickname" or "preferred form of address", which you could store as a separate opaque string, if you really want that.
- kibwen 10y agoYes, I'd so much rather have an explicit nickname field if a company wants to insist on calling me anything other than my username.
- Frondo 10y agoThat's great, that's an even better solution. I like that. If I'm ever in a position to make a recommendation about this sort of thing again, I'll use that idea.
- smallnamespace 10y agoBut sometimes your government expects names to be broken into given and family names (the US, Japan, and China all seem to make this assumption -- every government form I've seen from those countries wants your name fully broken out). I've no direct experience with, say, Russian or Latin American governments, but cultures that use explicit patronymic or matronymic names might expect that broken out as well. If you ever need to submit user data to the government (e.g. for tax reasons), and you don't ask your user to break the name apart, then you will necessarily be guessing, which seems strictly worse than just asking them how their name might split. At the end of the day, if you operate in a given culture, then you need to address those cultural norms. Bending over backwards to support every possible edge case seems unwise if they also happen to disagree with those norms.
- kibwen 10y agoI'm explicitly disregarding government websites here, since the government has a legitimate reason to care about my full name (and gets to define what a "legal" name means), and also 99% of the websites that I sign up for are unrelated to the government. There's no reason for a social network to report the names of all its users to a government agency automatically, and I'm skeptical that even my bank would have such a requirement.
- smallnamespace 10y agoI don't mean reporting all the names, but for example if you ever transmit payments there is a KYC process, and if you are a bank you must report any suspicious money laundering activity. At the end of the day there are cultural conventions around names, and various agencies use them. I don't see why software should be explicitly culturally neutral, unless your audience is explicitly a global one (and even then, I think localization is preferable to just sticking names into a single field).
- Thrillington 10y agoThere is significant engineering cost to implement localization correctly. If you're a bank or in another market where you interact with a government, then you must bear those costs. If not, why not just use an opaque string and spend your engineering dollars on your actual product?